That sentence could have applied to my fork in the road as well. To cut to the chase, I was dating a woman I’ll call Alison, and we were together dating a woman I’ll call Bianca. Even at the best of times, polyamory is like walking a tightrope blindfolded. And I suppose that, inevitably, there comes a point where someone in the relationship thinks that this whole group thing isn’t working, and so that person starts to think about choosing one person over the other.
Now Alison was the woman I was dating first. She was the safe choice I guess, in that she did genuinely love me, held a steady job, was always honest with me. A good partner in life, even if she was upset that Bianca didn’t love her more than she loved Bianca, and even if she was withdrawn at times.
“Withdrawn” was the last word to describe Bianca. She was incredibly spontaneous, the kind of person who’d be driving you somewhere and suddenly turn off the highway because “that tree over there looks neat, I have to see it close up.” To be honest, she was trouble on legs and she’d tell you that up front. She had difficulties with personal relationships, spending habits, showing up to important things like work, and basically was never all really there. She’d been bankrupt once and was heading that way again. (Thank god she never once asked us for money. I think she realized that would go over like an atom bomb.) She’d “done things” in the past she didn’t like to talk about. Considering the things she did talk about, I can only imagine what those were. Alison believed in auras and sometimes said “Bianca’s aura is plaid.”
And despite Bianca’s visible craziness…there was something honestly, overpoweringly, alluring about her. First of all, no woman has ever made it clearer that she was hopelessly, madly devoted to me. In a thread a while back I said that the superpower I wanted was to be able to look at someone like they were the only person in the world. That was because of Bianca, because she had that look down. Bianca would do things like spend two hours straightening her hair–she had really long hair–because earlier I’d made an off-hand remark that she looked good with straight hair. She made a genuine effort to become interested in the things I was interested in. She’d sneak little glances and smiles at me just for no reason. And without being too graphic, she’d go after me in bed as if I were the last man on earth–and she responded to me as if she’d been plugged into a light socket. When I stepped away from Bianca, I had to silently tell myself, “Barring a miracle, I will never, ever find a woman that good in bed again.” I have to admit that for a while Bianca seemed like the better choice. Maybe I could put up with someone who was so obviously a lost soul because, honestly, she just made me feel so wanted. I’d been through two relationships and failed marriage where I’d never even felt close to wanted.
But crazy ended up beating allure. For a while Alison and I kept up things with Bianca, realizing that we were hurting each other, all three of us, and that things were really never going to work out, and trying to admit that we weren’t going to cause permanent damage to ourselves. And then Bianca cheated on us. Maybe. Or maybe she said she was going to cheat on us because she was afraid of losing me because…look, Bianca’s mind was a dangerous place, I am not going to try to go back in there. And, where before I’d suggested to Alison we break up with her because I was afraid Alison would be hurt, now I said it because I didn’t want to see Bianca again. And so I chose safety over uninhibited passion. I don’t doubt my choice.