“The Shawshank Redemption” is a very good and popular movie.
There is a scene where the hero Andy Dufresne (Tim Robbins) puts a record on and plays a wonderful duet from the opera “The Marriage of Figaro” (see below).
Andys’ friend, Ellis (Morgan Freeman) notes that while the music was angelic he has no clue what they were singing about nor does he want to know because it would diminish the beauty of the song.
I missed the edit but I am curious if there are any other such songs where you love the music and think that somehow knowing what was being sung diminishes it somehow.
Put another way:
Do I want to know what those women were singing about in the movie?
Perhaps it was meant to be highly ironic, but, then again, Andy picked that record himself?
I believe they are just singing about their fake love letter to send to the count who wants to fuck the maid, etc
I mean, that’s what it’s about; they are singing about gentle breezes under the pines, etc in a language which most of the prisoners cannot understand anyway, but Andy probably knows full well what it’s about.
Man I seriously apologize if you did not want to know what they were singing about, but, in my defense, you mentioned straight off it was from “The Marriage of Figaro”, so at that point I did not imagine it was much of a spoiler.
While I certainly do not mind being told what they were singing about (see my previous post), more broadly, I think, is a discussion of if it is actually better not knowing and if there are other songs like that.
In that case, here is the relevant section on the movie script:
In other words, in the movie at least, not only does he pick that song out deliberately, but it is one of his favorites!
Here is the duet in English:
My take in this case is that the viewer is (ideally) supposed to recognize the song and know what it is about, the point is that Red decided he was better off not knowing, instinctively fearing it would not live up to his imagination. This may have to do with his character at that point: while he fantasizes about getting out of prison and moving to Mexico, when faced with actually doing so he nearly can’t hack it.