WHAT?! When did this happen?

Whilst reading an article yesterday on cnn.com about Peter O’Toole (who is refusing a “Lifetime Achievement” Oscar (how to you make the little TM thing?), I ran across this:

AMPAS execs and Oscarcast producer Gil Cates will discuss what to do in the event
O’Toole does not show up. This is uncharted territory: In the past, winning actors
such as Marlon Brando and George C. Scott have refused the Oscar, but no honorary winner has ever declined the prize.

I’ve looked an’ looked but can’t find out when or why. Anybody know what gives?

mmm…

Brando’s Awards (Refused Godfather Best Actor - 1973 over treatment on native Indians)

Scott’s Awards (Refused Patton Best Actor - 1970, didn’t think of himself as competing with other actors)

First, I apologize for not having a more descriptive thread title.

Second, thanks, Gyan, for your prompt response.

Third, I guess I wasn’t phrasing it correctly when I was searching ot something.

Have a swell day!
mmm…

A Indian received Brando’s award in his name and gave a protest speech. I don’t even think Scott showed up.

Yeah, but why is O’Toole refusing his award?

Actually, it was Maria Cruz who “accepted/refused” the award on Brando’s behalf. She pretended to be a Native American woman by the name of Sacheen Littlefeather.

Can’t Mark Linn-Baker keep him sober long enough to accept the award?

O’Toole’s said, basically, “I’m not dead yet!” From his statement it was clear to me that he thought this meant the Academy was writing him off as a legitimate threat to win an Oscar on his own, and he didn’t want to be part of that.

The Academy said the honorary award means no such thing, it’s just a recognition of his body of work.

You decide which is right.

Basically O’Toole feels that at 70, he is too young for a “Lifetime Achievement” award. He asked that they wait until he is 80, so he has more time to win a competitive reward.

It’s a little silly, because there’s nothing to stop him from winning a competitive award later and he certainly wouldn’t be the youngest to win Lifetime Achievement.

He is refusing it because he still hopes to win a real one.

Specifically, he responded to the notification of the award with a handwritten note that included the phrase, “I’m still in the game.”

The Thalberg award is usually awarded as a lifetime achievement sort of award, and Steven Spielberg won it BEFORE he won his regular Oscars.

Incidentally, I believe Peter O’Toole holds the record for most nominations for an actor without winning; he’s been up 7 times.

Perhaps someone could point out to O’Toole that Paul Newman reeived a Lifetime Achievement award the year before he won a competitive Oscar for “The Color of Money.”

Also Henry Fonda.

http://www.backstage.com/backstage/news/article_display.jsp?vnu_content_id=1806804

He’s tied with Richard Burton (his co-star in Becket).

http://www.washingtonpost.com/wp-srv/style/longterm/movies/features/oscars/actornoms.htm