I’ve only tried a few of them. Most, I guess, never make it out the area or the Northeast. As a whole, I remember them being quite nice, and of surprising quality. Decent quality/price ratio and I remember saying at the time that I’d buy some of them again. I desperately want to make it up to the Finger Lakes to go tasting, and also because it’s supposed to be really pretty. This site, looks like a pretty good resource for maps and contact info.
The Semi-Dry Riesling from Dr. Konstantin Frank, in particular, had some nice minerality with lime flavors, and medium weight (for Riesling.) I don’t remember the vintage. They don’t taste like Mosel-Saar-Ruwer Rieslings, but then again, neither does anyone else’s. I’d compare them to Alsatian Rieslings from a good producer, with a bit of residual sugar, so akin to some of Domaine Schleret’s stuff. I don’t mind RS, especially in Riesling, but YMMV. I’ve no idea what Frank’s vineyards are supposed to taste like, so I’ve no idea of their typicity. It was tasty enough to make me want to try more from the area.
Right now, our local gourmet supermarket is running a sale on Chateau Ste. Michelle’s “Eroica” Riesling at $15. Provided you like RS—it tastes quite sweet, despite the 1.6% RS, per its .pdf fact sheet here—it is a delicious wine. Not light bodied at all, rather it tastes like a good Spatlese/overripe Kabinett from a good Pfalz or Nahe producer, like maybe Kurt Darting. At $15, it is fantastic, and solves my ‘what to have with Thai food’ conundrums.
The RS amount and perception is really funny. From Eroica’s fact sheets, (which you can find here) the RS varies vintage to vintage from 1.6-2.1%. As I wrote above, it tastes to me noticeably sweet. Yet, from wiki’s description of RS and German wine grape ripeness classifications, that level of RS would normally have an indication of “halbtrocken” or “feinherb”. Non-halbtrocken Kabinett and Spatlese have RS’s between 3-6%, according to that chart. I’m not sure what the actual level of RS is in a typical Spatlese, say from Dr. Loosen’s Wehlener Sonnenuhr. But I’ve had halbtrockens—Selbach-Oster released a delicious one this year from Zeltinger Himmelreich—and they tasted less sweet to me than the Eroica. I just need to get them side-by-side and blind, I guess.
Would that winemaker’s provided as much info on their labels, as say Ridge Vineyards does.
(FWIW, most of the links in this post are .pdfs.)