What would happen to a John/Jane Doe?

So a person is brought into a hospital with no I.D. They don’t know who they are, no memory or fingerprint record. What happens next if they never remember and no one comes for them? (Is John or Jane Doe correct? I’ve only heard that in connection with deceased people.)

I’d guess they’d use DNA to try to match him through the various companies. If the patient refused, I’d be suspicious he was faking amnesia.

John or Jane Doe can be used for medical patients of unknown identity. I will note that an injury that genuinely wipes one’s memory has a high probability of killing one.

A situation where someone is able to sit up, speak coherently, interact with others, but has no memory of self it likely to be a psychological issues but that doesn’t automatically mean it’s “fake”, although questions will be raised. Dissociative fugue is a thing even if it is a very rare thing.

A variety of means will be used to attempt to identify the person, including fingerprints, DNA, and simply showing their picture on TV or other broadcast media.

If they can’t be identified there will be an attempt to rehabilitate the person to independence and a new identity established. They probably won’t retain a name like “John Doe” but choose something with less baggage.

Would they be helped to get new identification papers, like a driver’s license?

Need answer fast?

The case of Benjaman Kyle provides a good example of what might happen to an unidentified person.

Very interesting, thank you. There’s so many ways to hopefully discover who you were out there. Not a spelling of Benjamin I’ve seen before.

What an unsettling gaze in his photo in the Wikipedia entry. Staring out at you with an expression that seems to say, “Do you know who I am?”

I thought that, too, then read that he had cataracts in both eyes when found. I wonder if that expression is the result of spending who-knows-how-long squinting and nearly blind.

And finding out that he was older than he thought had to be a shock.

Very interesting case - hadn’t read of that before. I wonder how he ended up at the Burger King dumpster? Hope he’s doing much better now.

That hadn’t occurred to me, and you may be right. My interpretation’s more entertaining, though. :grinning: With all due respect, of course. Poor guy. At least he was (apparently) provided with good care.

In a thread from 2008, someone asked what would happen to an amnesiac person with no id, to which someone else replied that they wouldn’t have to worry about Krell technology:

What is Krell technology? I asked Uncle Google and the results did not clue me in.

https://
www.youtube.
com/watch
?v=f2BY
yeS-fIU

https://
www.youtube.
com/watch
?v=6Htq
VKs_xVE

Put each of those two URLs together into one line, since we’re not allowed to link to them.

Couldn’t you just tell us?

In the classic sci-fi movie Forbidden Planet the Krell were a super-advanced alien race who had built a technology so powerful that one only had to think of something and it would be created. Unfortunately, the technology was so powerful that it could reach deep into the user’s mind and bring up the most horrible thoughts and feelings one had ever imagined (“monsters from the id”)

An amnesiac, having no memories, would not trigger the disastrous flaw that destroyed the Krell and endangered our stalwart Earth heroes.

It’s about the fact that the person who asked the question in the 2008 thread confused an ID (an identification form) with the id in people’s minds. ID is capitalized on both letters. An id has both letters uncapitalized.

I see. And I’ve seen Forbidden Planet more than once but didn’t remember the term “Krell”. Thanks.

Why do you think you can’t post a YouTube link, and why did you write it out in the most unusable way possible?