Absolutely 100% not true and I left a doctor over that exact statement. I used to be able to swallow giant horse pills. Those big herbal supplement pills…I could swallow 3 or 4 of them at a time, no big deal. Eventually it got to the point that anything bigger than a Tylenol Caplet would get lodged in my throat.
I asked my ENT about it, he sent me for a barium swallow and it came back totally normal. At my next appointment (after the barium swallow) I said ‘so, what’s next’ and he said ‘nothing, you’re fine’. I tried to explain to him that I’m NOT fine, things are getting stuck in my food, it’s a problem for me. He said ‘well, you can eat right, you don’t choke on hamburgers or chicken or mashed potatoes, it’s all in your head’ at which point I told him that chicken actually does get stuck in my throat quite a bit (and pasta does as well and a few other things were culprits, beyond that I never really knew when it was going to happen), his reply to that was ‘it’s the way god made you, some people can’t play music, some people aren’t good at math, you don’t swallow food well, you just have to make sure you chew every bite really well, the barium swallow came back fine, we checked you out with the laryngoscope and that looked fine, everything is fine, it’s in your head blah blah blah’
So I found a GI doc and they suggested an endoscopy with dilation. I went in for that and afterwards, when they woke me up they told me my esophagus was so narrow they couldn’t even get the scope down. I’d have to come back a few weeks later when they could rent a pediatric scope from Children’s Hospital. When I came back for that one of the nurses commented on how tiny the scope was. They dilated me and made me come back a third time for another dilation because they can only stretch it so far each time (I think that’s normal).
Whenever someone says ‘you can swallow pills, it’s all in your head’, that’s the earful they get. Don’t get me wrong, if you try to swallow a pill and after you drink the water the pill is still in your mouth or you can cough it right back up, that’s one thing. But if it’s lodged in your throat, that’s different, that’s not in your head. You can’t mentally make it get stuck a few inches past your throat, you don’t have conscious control over those muscles.
Also, unless you eat rocks for lunch, keep in mind that food is soft and can conform to your throat and esophagus to help itself slide down, pills don’t do that. That’s why a person that gets an Excedrin stuck in their throat can still swallow a giant bite of hamburger with no problem.