I vaguely remember the John Lindsay mayoral election, only because my parents voted for different candidates. My mother, always willing to consider a third party candidate or even the occasional Republican, voted for Liberal Party candidate Lindsay, and my father, who voted for straight party Democrat, always, voted for the Democrat candidate. Lindsay won, and my mother wasn’t terribly kind about it. I wasn’t very old, so I probably don’t remember the actual election day, but later conversations.
I clearly remember the McGovern/Nixon election. I was almost six. My brother was a baby. I had to stand and wait by the clerks’ table, but my brother, who was 7 months old, got carried into the voting booth with my mother. I was jealous, and one of the clerks was letting me play with the sample ballot, and he asked me if I was going to vote for Big Bird. I was indignant, and told him that* if *I could vote, I would vote for McGovern, of course. Big Bird was not on the ballot, and would make a terrible president anyway. This was the first time I remember watching returns on TV with my parents.
Election days were very big in our family. My father was a precinct chairman, and my mother always worked at the polls, except when she had a child who wasn’t in school yet. I worked as a poll-book holder when I was 10, for a three hour shift, and every year after that, I was either a poll-book holder, a watcher, or canvassing for candidates outside the polls.
I voted for president for the first time in the Dukakis/Bush election. Not an auspicious start. I was 22. It was my third time voting, even though I went and registered on my 18th birthday. It was an off-year, though-- no election. I missed voting against Reagan for his second term by two months. So I didn’t get to vote until I was 19. I was an official, paid poll worker then, though, and was a poll worker every year until I was at Gallaudet, and then I voted by absentee the first time. I also voted by absentee when I was in the military. I have never missed an election. I have also worked at the polls sporadically since. When I have had a job with flexible hours, and not had a small child, I have usually worked.
The first time I voted for a non-Democrat was when I voted for a Republican who had a very good record on women’s issues (he’d been pro-ERA, and pro-choice), and was running against an anti-choice Democrat. I have since voted for another Republican, and a couple of Green party members, and a Libertarian, but mostly I vote Democrat. My policy generally is that I vote the person in local races, the issues in state races, and the party in national races, albeit, I can’t imagine an issue that would get me to vote for a non-Democrat governor. Choice, but I doubt Indiana would run an anti-choice governor.
TL;DR: McGovern/Nixon; almost 6; 19, because there wasn’t an election when I was 18-- first presidential was Bush/Dukakis.