I was going to suggest Alan Garner, but not The Weirdstone of Brisingamen, because the story itself is fairly standard fantasy, it’s the writing which makes is so special. And I love the book so much it would break my heart to see it butchered.
But Redshift could make a wonderful film, well-handled.
But one book which has all the elements for a good film is Emma Bull’s War for the Oaks. With Johnny Depp as the phouka!
I forgot to say that I read somewhere that there was a film in production of Elizabeth Goudge’s The Little White Horse. This was a much loved book of my childhood, so I await the film with some trepidation. I’m not sure the limpid innocence of the story can be recaptured some fifty years after it was written.
I started reading the series with The Dark Is Rising, and didn’t realize Over Sea, Under Stone was the first book until after I had finished the remaining books. After I had read it, I was disappointed. Nothing new really came to light (ha!), so I walked away thinking the book didn’t really fit with the others.
I disagree. He’s a very sympathetic character in The Dark Is Rising; in fact, he was pretty normal, an everyman (kid) who provided a way for me to relate to what was happening. He gets confused, makes mistakes and grows as a person. Probably a bit more reserved than most American characters, but I could relate to him.
In the remaining three, however, yeah, he’s more of a mini-Merriman. At that point, however, we’re supposed to be seeing what’s happening through other characters, so the depersonalization of Will doesn’t matter much; plus, it makes sense in regards to his training as an Old One.
Now, the Drew kids–them I could live without. I’m not sure how anyone else feels, but I was annoyed by these kids. Their presence in the books felt boisterous and loud; they didn’t feet with any of the other more muted and refined chracters. I kept wishing they’d go away.
Okay, you have a point about that particular book, but I stand by my statement that he would not be a good main character for the rest of the books. Maybe The Grey King as from Bran’s point of view? Although Will starts out the book as a sympathetic character.