I picked “not in this generation,” but I suppose it’s going to take a couple of them. It’ll fade to just another date when the majority of people living weren’t alive on 9/11/01. Frankly, I would have a hard time remembering when Pearl Harbor was if Arizona didn’t make a point of remembering the USS Arizona in particular.
It will never become “just another date” as long as we remember it chiefly by the date.
I don’t remember the date of the bombing of Hiroshima, because we call it “the bombing of Hiroshima,” not checks “the August 6th incident.”
Similarly, the Ecole Polytechnique massacre is frequently called “le 6 décembre” - the commemorative park is even called “Parc du 6-Décembre-1989” - so the date sticks in your head, even 21 years later. But nobody ever called the Dawson shooting “September 13,” so it’s much more difficult to remember even four years later.
Here’s an interesting article (in French): “Quand le 11-Septembre s’approprie le onze septembre” (“when September 11th [the attacks] takes over the 11th of September [the date of the year]”). It quotes a Washington Post poll that says that 95% of Americans remember the date of September 11, even though 30% do not remember that the attacks took place in 2001.
I’ve long found it provocative that, last year for example, people said, “Today is the 10th anniversary of September 11,” not “today is September 11.”
(Idle thought: how do they deal with this in Catalonia, where September 11 is the national holiday? There’s a Parc del Onze de Setembre in Barcelona. I wonder if it’s more common to call the holiday la Diada now?)
Agreed. For me, 9/11 is the anniversary of something else that I celebrate with loved ones every year. I was on the other side of the country and didn’t know anyone in NYC that day, so it had much less of an impact on me. The event I celebrate is always the first thing I think of, while the attack is sort of an afterthought.
And there were polls showing that a significant number of Americans didn`t know it happened in 2001 even in 2004 or 2005. Can you really say it’s more than just a date just because you remember the day, given that it has always been defined by the day it happened, if have no idea what year it occurred 4 or 9 years later? Obviously on the face of it, it’s not “just another date” to the 95% who know it, but they’re hardly honoring the victims or anything, they can’t even remember when it happened.
I was in the Pentagon that day, in fact the place hit my old office head on. I’m over it. People that were not involved directly can’t seem to let it go. It chaps my ass that people have gotten permanent disability from being nearby when it happened.
But then most people, and maybe this poll is only asking about the twin towers?
I think that 9/11 will be remembered by the generations that were old enough for it to have any significance until we die, much like the JFK assassination.
I was way too young to remember that, but Bigbro and the older cousins definately do (did). My mom can still tell you (even with memory impairment) what she was doing when she heard the news (JFK) and still gets choked up when she tells you. I do the same when speaking about 9/11.
An event that shakes us up as a people tends to affect us differently than personal tragedies. We’re all in the same boat, including the folks who would help you deal with something more personal.