Then read Larry Niven’s “All The Myriad Ways.”
Actually, since the directions to get to Neverland involve following a star, (admittedly not a well-identified one,) why couldn’t it be on an alien planet, with a magic way to get there?
That’s not a satisfying argument. Why would there be multiple universes? There’s no particular reason to assume the process would repeat itself. I’ve grudgingly accepted that there are probably other universes based on the probability arguments, but “why not?” doesn’t indicate that something has actually happened - just that it could.
But we have no knowledge of anything that would stop it from happening again, either. Claiming that our universe is the only one is the kind of assertion of specialness that historically has turned out to be wrong.