Good question, and (as a Strange fan) I’ve thought about starting this thread myself.
As a child in the '70s, I always saw Sean Connery in the role, which is obviously not going to work nowadays.
I love Johnny Depp, and while I don’t think he looks the part, if anyone ill-suited to the role could pull it off, I’m betting it would be him.
Timothy Dalton is an interesting choice, but I haven’t seen anything from him but the Bond film that he did (wow, a second Bond actor…trend?).
Jeffrey Combs would be interesting, though. I haven’t seen him in a while, but he kicked ass in the Reanimator movies.
I don’t wish to subvert astro’s OP, but two differences of opinion: I’ve only seen David Hyde Pierce as Frazier’s brother, and that show annoyed me to no end (even in the short bursts that I witnessed it), so a NO from me on that.
But also:
Might we expand this thread into casting a Doctor Strange movie in general, instead of just the lead role? I would have picked Jessica Alba as Clea, but since the F4 has ruined this concept, perhaps Scarlett Johansson?
I’ve always thought that good CGI was necessary to make a DS film, especially when there are excursions to the Dark Dimension of the Dread Dormamu! Roger Dean sould be a consulting artist on this.
The Time Has Come! Ia, Ia, Shub Niggurath!
(wait…maybe that’s someone else…)