Mr. Pundit and I are celebrating 25 years of marriage next year. We’re kicking around the idea of renting a house in the Caribbean next winter (Jan/Feb '14) and inviting 3 to 5 couples to join us. We’ve twice been to St. John and loved it, but I wanted to check out another island. Trouble is I know nothing about the other islands, and their websites only give you the positive stuff.
FYI, we’re in our late 40s and pretty active. We like sailing, fishing, hiking, zip lining, sand volleyball, tennis, etc. These are a few villas I’m eyeing.
http://www.vrbo.com/214580 (St. Marteen)
http://www.vrbo.com/344597 (St. Croix)
http://www.vrbo.com/1056402ha (St. Lucia)
Rum Point Vacation Rentals, North Side: house rentals & more | Vrbo (Cayman)
Any feedback on the individual islands or rentals is appreciated.