For those who prefer the George C. Scott version, may I ask if it was the first one you ever saw? I ask because I strongly suspect that people tend to prefer the one they saw first. I know I do. The Alistair Sim version was my first, and is still my favorite.
After seeing the new Jim Carrey version, I went on a *CC *kick, and have since watched *Scrooged *(again), the Sim version (for the millionth time), the Reginald Owen version, and the Scott version, neither of which I had seen before.
IMHO the Scott version is not only the worst of these, it is close to being the worst I can imagine. It is just appalling at almost every level. The production design depicts a Victorian England that is far too lavish and clean. The Cratchit family lives in a house that is practically palatial, and far from the hovel that virtually every other version correctly shows.
David Warner and Susannah York as Bob and Mrs. Cratchit are horribly miscast.
And Scott, while not miscast, completely phoned in his performance. There’s not a spark of life or feeling in it. No inspiration.
There was a lot else I didn’t like about it at the time, but I don’t remember all of it now. I recorded it and was planning to keep it, but I so disliked it I couldn’t imagine ever wanting to watch it again, so I deleted it.
The Owen version is good, but not quite as inspired as the Sim version, IMHO. But since I’m accusing others of it, I might be guilty of a bias in favor of the first one I ever saw. Last night I watched the Sim version from a newly restored Blu-ray version that is just gorgeous.
Although the new Jim Carrey one has a few flaws, it may be the most faithful version ever done. I could be wrong, but having just re-read the original tale, I believe that virtually every line in the 2009 film is straight from the text of the story. It also contains a few things that few or no other versions have done.
For instance, Scrooge criticizes the Ghost of Christmas Present for closing bakeries on Sundays so the poor can’t have a hot meal one day a week. The GOCP basically says, “Don’t blame me for what the priests do.” I.e., an anti-religion message.
It also shows a guide dog leading a blind man away from Scrooge’s frightful presence, which is straight from the book. (I just noticed that the Sim version includes this, which I hadn’t remembered.)
The worst flaw of the new Disney version is the inexplicable rollercoaster ride (featured in most of the ads for the film) after Scrooge meets the Ghost of Christmas Yet to Come. That and the appalling attempt that Carrey makes at a Yorkshire accent (I think that’s what he was trying for) as the GOCP. Otherwise it’s pretty good.