I didnt read every post here but a few things jumped out at me, allow me to to offer some first hand observations. I have been in the adult industry for more than 20 years and I specialize in the “amateur” genre.
#1 there is no such thing as free porn…no matter how much you may wish to fool yourself everyone is making money on it. the couples who film it, even the tubesites offering it for free.
most of the “amateur” scenes on those tubesites are stolen not as in from someone sock drawer but as in off the girls for profit website or mine.
and you are paying for them, pornhub and similar sites are mining all sorts of private data from you everytime you use it and they are selling that data and they are selling you as traffic and as was noted advertising but the real money isnt the advertising its the selling of the site visitor and his/her info.
To the OP’s question thats much more complex.
First you can’t conflate your morality onto someone else these days. so toss the morality arg out the door right off the bat.
by and large the age group that I am looking for to be in my product is 20-30 thats an age group where the average pay for a single boy girl scene can be a minimum of 80 hrs working a regular job…all in 2 hours for doing something they ae all already doing anyway.
There is a much much less guilt associated with sex these days so a lot of the girls doing it dont have a shred of regret or guilt about it.
Given these things the biggest single factor I run into is that it is validation that she is still pretty. The number of girls I shoot that were cheerleaders, homecoming court and the like is very very high these girls get out of high school and into college and they go from being in the “in crowd” to being a nobody and in a society these days where attention is synonymous with success its instant validation.
another factor is that its an easy way to get things that they want and get them quickly, this ties to the money aspect but if you are raising a daughter these are things you da,mn well better be paying attention to.
then comes daddy issues…the high rate of divorce these days translates into abandonment issues usually right at the moment that it has the most psychological effect. I can say without fail that no matter what the other reasons there are always daddy issues. In many cases as I develop friendships with these girls I become the surrogate daddy…this was especially true when I owned and managed a strip club. I tried to do right by them, encouraging then to get an education, health insurance, pursue their interests and give them relationship and common sense advice…many times I am telling them the same thing that their mom and or dad is but coming from me it seems to carry more weight…and thats because unlike mommmy and daddy I NEVER EVER lie to them…I dont tell them fairy tales about santa claus, religion, toothfairy and if they need to lose a few pounds I tell them the truth. This may sound insensitive but I could write a book on the good things that have happened because of it. In the end its the one thing I think should be the teachable moment in all of this dont lie to your kids, ever, about anything, if you expect them to trust you when they get older don’t betray that trust for 15 years and then expect them to suddenly believe that NOW you are being honest.
BTW I do speak on this topic and in most cases will do so for expenses, so if youd like me to spea to your church group, civic organization or whatever contact me via email. believe me I know where parents make mistakes that make it easy for daddys little snowflake to justify doing porn, and once they do it once, its a hundred times easier the second time.