So, in The Who’s song “Who Are You?” in the chorus Pete is singing:
Who are you?
(background): who who who who
Yah, tell me who are you
(background): who who who who
Then it sounds exactly like he says:
Who the fuck are you?
But they play this on the radio. Also I cannot find any place that shows lyrics on their sites where it says this. But it sounds just like Pete says “fuck”.
I always thought it was “Who the fuck are you?”, too, but I assumed they edited it when they played it on the radio.
In R.E.M.'s “What’s The Frequency, Kenneth?” right at the end after he sings “I never understood” instead of singing “the frequency” as he had through the rest of the song, Michael Stipe slips in “Don’t fuck with me”; that one got airplay, although it is a bit inaudible.
Since the whole Janet Jackson Superbowl flap broadcasters have gotten a lot more paranoid about stuff that might get them in trouble with the FCC. But Who are you has been playing on the radio for decades, so I guess it’s kinda grandfathered in. If a new song came out with the word fuck, it would probably get edited from the start.
No doubt if the radio station got complaints they’d edit the word out. It also helps that if you’re not really listening for it it’s not too obvious.
Although I noticed several months ago (not long after some radio stations were getting FCC fines for indecent material) that one of the local rock stations edited the word ‘bullshit’ out of Pink Floyd’s Money. This is a song that the station had been playing for the last thirty years and now, all of a sudden, the word’s too terrible for us to hear. :rolleyes:
I remember hearing it on FM radio when it was a Top 40 hit in 1978, and the “Who the fuck are you?” was there, unedited. I thought “hmm!” at the time, but FM radio always seemed to have more leeway than AM. For years I had been hearing Pink Floyd’s Money on FM radio with the lines, “Money, it’s a hit / Don’t give me that do-goody-good bullshit.”
I read at the time that there was a special edit available to radio stations that had “who the hell are you” replacing the naughty line. I don’t believe I ever actually heard that version, though.
I believe the version on the radio they snipped the end off that line to “do-goody-good-bull”. I think I have heard both versions of “Who Are You” on the radio though.
I’d say the Stones get away with more sleaze in their lyrics than anyone else. But most of the Stone’s songs take several years of listening to figure out what Mick’s saying anyway.
Yes, he says “fuck.” And Steve Miller says “shit” in “Jet Airliner” and Mick Jagger sings “You make a dead man cum” in the last line of “Start Me Up,” all heard on classic rock stations.
But you can be sure that Microsoft didn’t use that last line when they licensed the song for their promotions about ten years ago.
Re “Walk On The Wild Side”: the single version omits the “giving head” verse. It times out almost a minute shorter, IIRC. Unfortunately, our classic-leaning AAA opts to play the short, edited version as a rule, so I hear the edited one practically every time it plays.
When John Mellencamp’s Play Guitar was in heavy rotation, Indy’s top radio station made a doctored tape with shit played backwards. It came out, “Forget all about that macho tish, and learn how to play guitar.”