Janet Reno?
Rick Hoffman is currently playing a jerk partner attorney in USA’s “Suits”, which if you haven’t seen, you should - it’s quite good, and he really seems to be having fun with his role 
Speaking of whom, I once posted a question on another board in which I was trying to identify Hoffman. I could think of a recent program he had been in, but I didn’t catch the name or the title. I described him as best I could, and while I did get ultimately get a response, before that, one person sent this rendering of him, based on my description. No kidding!
That rendering should get added to his IMDb page!
Rick Hoffman in all his Google Images glory:
My first thought was David Leisure.
Can you link us to the internet dating match?