Who wants to defend pirating content (movies/music/books/software/whatever)?

How’s this sound, instead - the hypothetical you propose in that thread has fuck-all to do with the scenario I posted above where I expressed some minimal support for stealing software.

Or, to put it another way: Fallacy of the excluded middle.

Not caring enough to have an opinion about something I never do and that is done by people who aren’t me to other people who aren’t me makes me a hypocrite?

Ok then… I’m a hypocrite. :dubious:

I have no particular dog in this fight, but i just wanted to say that you could have enticed people into your thread by being a bit less of a dick.

Instead of barging in and saying “Perhaps none of you have seen it. Otherwise, I’ll assume you’re just hypocrites,” you might have said something like: "I’ve just started a new thread in GD about violating the copyright of open-source software. I’d be interested to hear opinions from people who have supported, or refused to condemn, copyright violations in this thread.

Flies, honey, vinegar, etc.

Look six posts above yours (#257).

I decided that, after a month of no bites, it was time to try a different bait. This is the Pit, after all.

Fair enough; i didn’t see the earlier link.

Still, i’m not sure that people’s absence necessarily denotes hypocrisy. Perhaps apathy?

  1. You’re right that I haven’t seen it. And now that I have, I don’t care. You’re asking a specific question about a specific kind of piracy; a subject which holds no interest or relevance to me personally.

  2. I didn’t see your thread therefore I’m a hypocrite? Feel free to fuck off and die whenever you get the chance, little attention whore.