Inspired by this Pit thread in which the OP is outraged by the presence of a convicted and paroled rapist of a child in his workplace.
In the above-linked thread, several people express dismay that we as a nation have a double-standard when it comes to sex crimes (specifically rape and child molestation). We’ll eventually release offenders (and not after sentences so long that the ex-cons are so enfeebled that no one’s worried about them), but place every obstacle in their path to reintegrate into society. Others agree, and opine that such people should be quickly executed.
Well, why don’t we? According to Wikipedia only Louisiana specifically executes child rapists, and Florida executes for “capital sexual battery”. Four other states execute for aggrevated kidnapping, and I can only assume the rape is an aggrevating factor. No one has been executed for anything other than murder since 1964, although Lousiana has one child molestor on death row. Why such a low rate?
It seems clear to me that most people believe that rape, especially when a child is involved, to be the foulest of crimes, and often as bad or worse than murder. Hell, even a bleeping heart liberal like me has no trouble treating rapists and murderers the same. In addition, to be cynical for a moment, it seems to me that there’s political points to be made in volunteering (as some did in the Pit) to kill rapists. But there hasn’t been a successful movement to execute such criminals. This seems odd to me, although I admit that my judgement may be clouded by my belief that the death penalty is never justified (a position I’m not trying to debate right now, if you don’t mind).
Why don’t we execute rapists more often? Is it that the current level of horror at such crimes is so new that the law hasn’t caught up yet? Is it that the (factually dubious) meme that sex offenders have a tremoundously high rate of recidivism is too recent or too weak to have an effect on the legislatures? Or do the death penalty proponents have a more consistent stance that only murder deserves the death penalty than I give them credit for.