Why does a dog wag it's tail?

If this has been discussed, then I apologize. I have searched but couldn’t find anything on it.

But I wonder: why does a dog wag it’s tail when it is happy? Cat’s have tails and they can be happy to see you, but they don’t wag their tails. Dogs go nuts with their tails when they are happy or excited. So what gives? I have a dog that had his tail cut off to practically nothing by his first owner, and he must know that, because when he wags his “tail” (nub) he actually wiggles his entire ass. Is there any scientific reason why a dog wags its tail when excited? (Or for that matter put their tail between their legs when scared? Although that seems to make more sense because it does seem to be defensive and shows submission. Need me to elaborate on my reasoning there more? I will if you like.)

I can’t remember where I read this (DogWatching maybe?) but the author suggested that dogs wag their tail for the same reason cats do: when they’re torn between 2 choices and can’t make up their minds what to do.

So a dog might wag it’s tail when it’s excited to see you, but is (understandably) a bit frightened of Mr Pack Leader (in doggy terms). Cats don’t do this because they don’t like you anyway; they’re only in it for the food :slight_smile:

Being a pack animal dogs need to have some means of communication.

Gestures such as the way the head is held or the manner in which it walks can have important meanings to other dogs which help hold the heirarchy together and reduces serious and possibly fatal disputes.

Our domestic dogs exhibit many characteristics of very young juveniles rather than full adult animals.

One characteristic is when your dog greets you, some will approach you with their head held low, will not make eye contact and hold their tail low with small almost feeble wagging movements. Many owners will recognise those signals when their dog greets them in this way, the dog knows it has broken some rule, maybe emptied the trashcan or ripped something apart. This is their “I’m as guilty as hell and I’m really really sorry look”
They may well be fearing some beating as the owner gets emotional and irrational so they try to show submission.

Other times when you come home the dog sees you as a hunter returning with the spoils, you may have lots of interesting smells so you might well be inspected, in a respectful way of course, and there might even be the possibility of food to share.

Many dogs do get fed fairly shortly after their owners return from work, and many also get a chance to go walkies, which to the dog is a time to get completely hyped up ready for the pack going hunting.

Your dog may just go completely over the top trying to show you how loyal he is and how jolly glad he is for your return, this is where the tail goes mad, knocking cups off tables, banging against doors, he may dash off and fetch you a favourite item of his as a kind of gift or maybe to remind you that he is expecting his gift from you, it kind of depends on his mood.

Other times like say when you are sat in your front room and your dog sidles past on his way to lie in front of the fire (usually too close than is good for him!) he will give you a slow glance and gently wave his tail just once or twice as if to say “Hi, don’t worry about me I’m cool”

One of the funniest I’ve seen is when a huge animal decides it is still a puppy and can sit on your lap, they kind of creep up watching you, but look away instantly everytime you make eye contact and stop moving, the moment you look away they start up again and slowly try to insinuate themselves onto your lap, the tail flickers very slightly as if to say “Please be nice I’m really very small and you will hardly notice me”
This is often accompanied by some comedic clumsiness where you get a wet nose poked in your eye and an ungainly balancing act as paws slide around trying to gain purchase until it all falls apart and cups of coffee go flying one way, newspapers another and the dog trying to look as innocent as possible.

casdave, I just had to say thanks for the laugh! You described in perfect detail my boyfriend’s two dogs. too funny!

I have nothing else to add, how can you add to perfection?

But why dont humans shake their butts back and forth and to and fro when we are faced with a difficult decision. It sounds like quite an experience.

Apparantly you don’t go to the right bars. :wink:

It can be! :smiley:

:smiley: I have a dog like that, too. It cracks me up.

Actually, I have a kitten that wags its tail quite a bit when it’s happy. He also drinks out of the toilet. I think we need to get another cat to teach him proper kitty behavior, because he seems to be having an identity crisis with only the dog around.

I have a 115 pound German Shepherd with this problem. He tries to climb into my lap then tries to roll over so I can rub his belly; quite funny if you can keep breathing.

In one of his books didn’t Vonnegut write about a dog that couldn’t wag his tail so he always had to fight? Slaughterhouse Five maybe . . .

The same reason we smile when we’re happy: instinct, plus a little societal reinforcement.

My dog used to wag its tail when it was happy or when a stranger came to the door; now it only wags when it has to go walkies. Wonder how it learned that behaviour?

I have to confess that my post was inspired by another poster in another dog thread, can’t remember who but it did put me in mind of a friend who owned a big labrador that used to try sit on her lap.

As another dog owner 9and student of canine behavior), I have this to contribute: my springer spaniel has only about a 3" length of tail-but he sure does move it! I’ve noticed thew aforementioned tail-down, guilty as hell look-when he has done something wrong! he is a great hound, and I am always amazed by how much he can pick up from us humans-here’s one for you: he loves to wrestle and roughouse with me and my stepson. On occasion, he will clamp his jaws around my forearm, and very GENTLY, squeeze down-at that point he will look into my eyes, as if to say"foolish human-I can break your feeble arm if I want to"…but beeing friends, he just lets me go!

I apologize for this, but I feel I must drop this little line from the movie.

“Cause if the tail was smarter, it would Wag the Dog.”

Scientific answer coming up:

Dogs have scent glands near their anuses, when they wag their tail, it actually is dispersing their scent. This is why dogs sniff each others butt’s, to smell their scent, not their anus.

Of course they also wag when they are happy, but you did ask for a scientific reason as well.

Gotta love Animal Planet sometimes!

One thing that makes me grin hugely is when one of my dogs sort of catches his/her upper lip on a tooth so that it looks like a Billy Idol sneer, especially when accompanied by that head cocked to one side look, ears all perked up.

They wag their tails for the same reason they lick their testicles…

** BECAUSE THEY CAN! ** :smiley:

It must be told: My old dog Bear (rest his soul), a Lab-Vieshla mix, would wag his tail against the furniture, walls, etc., so hard that it bled, and then proceed to splatter blood all over the place: Our kitchen often looked like an axe murderer had been through. He never seemed to notice, though.

Different schools of thought on this one…

dylan mentioned one early in the thread: Desmond Morris postulated in DogWatching that dogs wag their tales when they are insecure or unsure about what decision they need to make, kind of a “should I go this-a-way or that-a-way” kind of thing.

Stanley Coren has a different view in How to Speak Dog. The tail can send quite a variety of signals, and is an important tool in dog communication, with variation in things like tail position, shape, and movement. Different combinations can mean happiness, fear, attention, aggression, dominance, submission, excitement, tension, or puzzlement.

I tend to lean more towards Coren’s analysis, primarily because of other postures and behaviors seen during tail-wagging, and the context in which it occurs.

But I think the most logical answer is “because it feels good.”