[QUOTE=cmkeller]
That makes no sense, if there is no collusion. Every customer that goes to ExxonMobil for gas isn’t going to BP-Amoco (et al) for gas, and vice versa. In a free market, BP-Amoco (et al) should logically be trying to get the customers currently buying from ExxonMobil.
Who says a given company couldn’t produce or procure more if they were getting more customers? I haven’t seen any shortages at the pump. If they’re selling all they can get their hands on, there should be occasional unavailability, shouldn’t there?
[/QUOTE]
You’re confusing the issue by conflating the price of crude and the price of gasoline at the pump.
Crude is a commodity, and it trades at whatever rate the commodity exchange determines. An oil company could theoretically sell its oil for less than the exchange price, but there’s absolutely no reason to do so, since they can sell every barrel they produce at the exchange price. That’s what I was talking about, since the OP is ostensibly about the price of crude oil.
The price of gasoline is determined by the wholesale price from the refinery (which is also based on the commodity exchange), plus (I think) the cost of transporting it to the particular gas station. Gas stations mark the gas up at a fairly small margin. From what I understand, they frequently don’t turn a profit on the gas when you take into account the station’s fixed costs (labour, property lease/tax/whatever, building maintenance, etc), relying instead on overpriced soft drinks and snack foods to stay in the black. Gas stations really have very little flexibility in what price they set unless the station owner is willing to lose money on gasoline sales.
So, where does competition for customers come into play? The price of crude and the price of wholesale gasoline are fixed on commodity exchanges, and are affected by global supply and demand (in the case of crude) or regional, often continental, supply and demand (in the case of gasoline). And by the whims of traders, who get skittish when things like political unrest in Venezuela or military conflict in Iraq threatens global oil production levels, or hurricanes threaten to shut down refineries on the Gulf Coast, pushing the exchange prices up due to an expectation of decreased supply, even if ultimately the supply doesn’t actually decrease. This is no different from the price of soy beans or the price of gold or the price of hog bellies. There is competition here, but it isn’t direct competition for customers. There’s no sense in selling below the market price, but as the market price goes up, producers have more incentive to produce, increasing supply and eventually bringing the price down, other things being equal. This happens with oil when oil companies fire up various pumping sites only when crude prices are over $X, because at prices below $X those particular sites aren’t profitable. And, higher prices might make the Saudis decide to open up a few more taps, and in the long term, higher prices provide incentive for oil companies to develop offshore oil, or invest in the capital-intensive process of getting at Alberta’s tar sands, or building a new refinery, etc.
But the only direct competition for customers is between individual gas stations, and as we have seen, gas stations do not dictate what they pay for wholesale gas, and have only a very small markup on the gas. This gives them bugger all room to compete with each other directly on price. Instead, they compete mostly by other means - convenience, service, location, better coffee than the next guy, free coke when you buy more than 30 litres, etc. The only time there’s really any direct price competition between stations is after peaks in the wholesale prices. Take, for example, the period of time following the price spikes after Katrina last summer. Wholesale gasoline prices went through the roof, and gas stations were forced to jack up their prices (and some gambled that consumers would panic and buy at any price, and gouged on top of that). But then it became apparent that there wouldn’t be any largescale shortages, and the wholesale prices settled down. And as they were settling, there’s a lag between the wholesale price dropping, and when the station drops its price. When should the station drop its price (from a profit-maximizing standpoint)? Well, that depends on what the station across the street does. No later than the station across the street, for sure. But the gas in the station’s tanks was purchased at the old, higher wholesale price, so you’d really prefer to keep your price up till you’ve sold this lot. Depending, the station across the street might be in the same boat, so neither of you will move the price down for a few days. Or maybe he’s NOT in the same boat, and drops his price, forcing you to follow suit and eat the loss on the remaining gas in your tank. So there you have direct competition. But that’s about the only place in the whole process.