[QUOTE=FoieGrasIsEvil]
The Wii’s only flaws are an apparent lack of relevant titles that appeal to the hardcore RPG/FPS gamer, and lack of CVG-quality graphics. That’s pretty much IT.
[/QUOTE]
Going for the FPS/RPG/graphics gamer would have killed this system just like it killed the last two. Nintendo already lost that battle twice, and once again they would have lost, because I doubt the gamer-Wii would not have supported Blu-Ray or HD-DVD.
Nintendo had to do something different or they were going to be in third place. So they have a system that appeals to a new audience, has a different experience than just more buttons and smaller pixels, and doesn’t need the latest home AV equipment to run at its best (but it runs just fine on the latest stuff). On top of all that, it’s $100-$200 cheaper than the alternatives. That’s why the Wii is successful. If you want what the other consoles offer, buy them - you were probably going to anyway.
For the non-gamer market, I’d say that not only is Wii Sports the killer app, but Mii Channel is, too.
The Wii is not without its faults, sure - the 480p mode compares unfavorably to the HD modes on the other two systems at first glance, and Wii Sports doesn’t do any favors here. Mario Galaxy pulls it off pretty good, though.
Quite a few of the early set of games for the Wii had the feeling that they were just Gamecube games with Wiimote controls patched on – because they were.
Online play could be better - I’m still unclear on which games can be played head-to-head online. It seems some games that support online play on other systems don’t on the Wii, and I don’t know if that’s a publisher thing or a Wii thing. The lack of voice chat doesn’t bother me, but I can certainly see the appeal.
I don’t have any opinion on the VC other than that I’m happy to see I can finally get Zelda 3 (which wasn’t included on the Zelda compilation I got with my Gamecube), and the real SMB 2. I do kinda wish they were cheaper, but really $5-$10 isn’t that bad.
The Wii does have games that suck (so does any console), but really, games are $50 so it’s not like you need 100 top quality games to have a good catalog - I’ll bet the average Wii owner will buy less than 1 game a month.
I’m just hoping the sports publishers don’t abandon the Wii like they did the Gamecube. I’m glad to see NCAA 2009 will be available on the Wii, since EA dropped the NCAA line from the gamecube in like 2004. Hopefully the strong console sales will keep the publishers around, and they won’t be scared off by the Wiimote. I would have considered buying and Xbox360 for better sports games, but it seems like much of big games for Xbox are FPS, and I got sick of FPS and online shoot-em-up playing Quake during college. The Wii “experience” attracted me to purchase a Wii instead. I probably would have sat this generation out, otherwise.