Why is there no common solution for "hat hair" when hats used to be ubiquitous?

In former times, within living memory even, a hat was an all but mandatory accessory for men of all classes in Western society. You didn’t leave the house without a hat on, and per standard etiquette, you took it off when going back inside a house.

In the wintertime especially, I wear hats a lot. Baseball caps are also very common these days, many people don’t even take them off indoors (in breach of said etiquette), probably because when they come off, voila, hat hair!

The only way I’ve found to wear a hat without severe hat hair is either (a) to wear a size slightly too large, which doesn’t press as tightly on the hair but does make it easier for the hat to blow away, or (b) to wear a very close cropped hairstyle. And even solution (a) doesn’t help when the hat in question is a wool skullcap meant to cover the ears.

You’d think that with all the ingenuity Man exhibited in the 19th and early 20th Centuries - trains, planes and automobiles, heck even the development of the brassiere as we know it today - something would have been developed for hat hair that didn’t involve a handful of wet glop used to turn hair into wire coils.

Was that, in fact, the standard solution? Were pretty much all those fedora and porkpie wearing men in the US in the 1940s laying them on top of a layer of Brylcreem or something? Eeew.

Mens’ hair tended to be quite short across the board. Maybe a few “artistic” types but they wouldn’t be wearing the establishment type hat anyway.

Yep. Very short haircuts and lots of Brylcreem or Vitalis.

You got something against Wildroot Cream Oil, Charlie? Or do you prefer Vitalis over that greasy kid’s stuff?

Men used hair dressing and they commonly carried pocket combs.

Note that people wore hats back then, not baseball caps. A baseball cap it tight against the hair; the hats wore in the past – fedoras, trilbys, derbys, etc. – only touched the hair along the sweatband.

I don’t have a problem messing with my hair when I wear a stiff felt hat with room for my hair.

And women’s hairstyles tended to be flat and smooth across the crown and back of the head with fluff and curls around the ears, back of neck, and forehead. I have some makeup and beauty books from the 30’s and 40’s and the hairstyles are quite compatible with hats.

Check these out: RetroBelles.com is for sale | HugeDomains

And a fedora doesn’t fit snugly like a baseball cap.