Why not vaccinate in the butt?

I doubt any of the branches did. Those three shots probably cost the military less than $3, and most went for the syringes. The test probably cost about $20.

When my son needed a painful antibiotics shot, and another shot of some kind when he was 4, and in the hospital (1 night) with croup, two nurses came in, and simultaneously stabbed him in each thigh. It was probably better than doing them sequentially, allowed me to comfort him immediately, and also kept him from reaching down and interfering with a shot, since there were two.

On the afternoon drive this afternoon there was a discussion about what testing still needs to be done for vaccines to be okay for children. One MD said when his 70+ mother, who was very petite, received her shot it made her arm swell up very badly, like three or four times its normal size.

The DHS people were very interested in the reaction figuring it had to do with her size and extrapolating it to child-size. The MD predicted kids would get their shot in the thigh or buttock rather than the arm.

I don’t know where research is, but it has to be determined whether hormone levels in kids make any difference, and what implications might be for growth. It’s probably the case that nothing in the shot itself adversely affects growth, but if there is a rare allergic reaction, or some other bad event, are the treatments for it safe or children, particularly do they not affect growth.

I don’t think it’s common for kids to get any shot in the arm. I don’t think my son had a shot in the arm until he was about 10, and he’s a really big guy.

All my (recent) kids childhood vaccinations were arm/shoulder shots.

As were my kids’ vaccinations in the mid-late '90’s.

I think it depends on age- as I said above, my memory is that my kids got vaccinations in the thigh when they were very young ( I think until they were 18 months or so ) and by the time they were five-ish, the vaccinations were in the arm. I can’t imagine trying to give a 6-18 month old an injection in the arm.

But (again, according to my memory) most vaccinations were before 18 months. There were only a couple of vaccinations given around the age of five - some booster shots. Then the next vaccine was around 12-ish which would almost always be in the upper arm.

My son has gotten a flu shot every year.

He was born in October, and didn’t get one that year, but he was breastfed, and I got mine early that year, when I was still pregnant, which I did on purpose.

He’s gotten one every year since, at his well-child check-up.

I got my military vaccines in the early 90s, and most of them were done with the gun, and in the arm. By the time my son got vaccines (b. 2006), the gun was gone. I just Googled, and apparently while they were much lower risk for disease transmission than, say, reusing a needle, they were not zero-risk, and using a different needle each time is zero-risk (well, there’s human error risk, but even with no human error, the risk with the guns is not zero).

If your kids got gun vaccines, they may have been in the arm.

They never got gun vaccines. Only regular injections.

I don’t recall kids getting flu shots when my kids were getting vaccinated in the 90s. So your son was getting flu shots in his butt or thigh when he was 7- 10ish?

Thigh.

Flu shots for kids are a 21st century thing-- I didn’t get them in the 1970s or 80s. But yeah, he has had one since he was one. I think the pediatric recommendation is to begin vaccinating at the first flu season after the child is six months. They may even vaccinate out-of-season if the baby isn’t breastfed, but I don’t know.

ETA: in the thigh, IIRC. I don’t think he got anything in the butt.

“In the butt” is a bit misleading if you don’t know what they are talking about. It’s the muscle at the top of the butt. (If anybody was getting penicillin actually in the ‘cheek’, somebody was doing it wrong.)

Yeah. I know. I got many a shot there, because I had strep about three times a year from age three to age 11, more or less. It how I ended up allergic to penicillin, and PANDAS. Kids who get this can behave very oddly when infected with strep. It might be how my insomnia got started, because the first time I remember having it was during a bout of strep. I was also experiencing psychotic-level paranoia, and when I did sleep (mostly during the day), bizarre dreams.

Are they still doing the nasal-spray flu vaccine for children? I’ve heard different things about this.

It is back to being as recommended as the injectable form for children 2 and up. It has been reformulated to be as protective as the injectable from. Pediatricians are advising all children 6 months and up to be vaccinated by one or the other flu vaccine.

As a nurse who did mass vaccination clinics, the injectable is easier to administer and I actually prefer it for my grown-up self. Go figure.

I got the nasal spray fly vaccine once, as an adult. It kinda gave me flu in the nose. I could smell flu for way too long. I didn’t realize i knew the odor of flu until i got it, but i had flu a lot as a kid, and I recognized that smell, it was the smell of sickness.

That being said, other than the nasty smell, my worst symptom was a slightly runny nose, and I disliked it less than i dislike injections.

The guy ahead of me in line had the medic sneeze just as he pulled the trigger, making a half-inch bloody gash in the guy’s arm. I’ve not been a fan of the guns ever since.