Why so few blind jazz guitar greats? Or any type of guitar great?

Why is it that there are, apparently, so few famous blind guitarists? It is true that in the era of southern folk blues there were Blind Blake, Blind Willie McTell, and others, but given the time, place, and economic conditions faced by rural blacks, a guitar was an obvious first choice, since it was relatively cheap or could even be home-made. Ray Charles, in his memoir, even said that he refused all along to play guitar, because he didn’t want to be another “poor blind blues guitar player”. One can only wonder at the loss to the guitar playing world.

There are a number of blind pianists who have achieved great prominence in jazz and blues–George Shearing, Henry Butler, and Ray Charles to name but three. But aside from those early blues guitarists, I can’t think of a single prominent blind guitarist. Of course, there is Jose Feliciano, but he seems to be better known for his writing and singing than as an instrumentalist.

Being an avid guitarist now, and having played piano earlier in my life, I can say that, at least for me, the guitar is more tactile, and, I would think, easier to play blind. Although I became quite proficient at playing ragtime, and was able to push aside any stage fright to play in public a few times, I always had to look at what I was doing on the keyboard, especially the left hand. I could never sight read; instead I would listen to a recording, and use the score to understand the arrangement, and then slowly play it, in a three-step process. Gradually I would get up to tempo and then be able to perform it by heart.

On the other hand, with guitar I have a much better feel for where my left hand is on the neck, and I don’t need to look nearly as much as I did with piano. I can read and play a simple classical piece and hardly need to look at the guitar at all. Given this, wouldn’t one expect to see more prominent blind guitarists today?

I don’t know the answer to your question, but Jeff Healy was blind.

Jose Feliciano/Flight of the Bumblebee

My guess would be, it used to be that someone who was born blind had to turn to music as a way of making a living, because there was nothing else they could do. Nowadays, with the technology we have, the world is simply more accessible for someone who’s blind, so they have more options,.

Well, calling him a guitar great would be an overstatement, but I do really enjoy Raul Midon:

Music has also become much more professionalized. Unless you are a truly rare talent, learning theory is crucial, and without written notation it is exponentially more difficult to do.

I also wonder if, once you reach the era of music schools, etc. (i.e., not some poor, unschooled blind guy who had to teach himself blues guitar to survive), fewer blind musicians were trained on guitar than on more traditional and “respectable” instruments, like piano.

Nobody ever walks off with your piano.

I think that up until maybe the mid-20th century, piano was a much more popular instrument than guitar, so that’s part of it. Coinciding with the “piano more popular” era was both the necessity of blind folks (due to lack of public sufficient public assistance) to make money at something and the public’s curiosity at blind folks making music. Once the guitar era was well in place, we had Social Security and the like, reducing the need for blind folks to have to get out there and earn money (this is a sweeping generalization, I know) or they were able to enter the workplace in other areas of endeavor. Also, once we got things like movies, radio and television, there was less of a need to go see blind folks play as entertainment.

He was also passionate about jazz music. He had a collection of over 30,000 vintage 78 r.p.m. jazz records, which he played on the air during his radio shows, had a band called “The Jazz Wizards,” and had released several albums of American jazz from the 20’s and 30’s towards the end of his life.

OK, well I do stand corrected about Feliciano, but even so I think he’s better known for his cover of Light My Fire (which the Doors all loved because it was inventive, rather than just copying them), and pop songs like Feliz Navidad.

I’m sure this has less to do with his being blind than it does to do with media acclaim to focus on singing only. Even with the talent reality shows now, we see singers heavily favored. There’s one on now to find the next country music star, and I’m sure it’s going to be all about the singing. They will not give the prize to a person who can play guitar like Roy Clark or Merle Travis, unless they can also sing like Garth Brooks or–ummm–sorry don’t know any female country stars.

What’s sad is that there is undoubtedly a great deal of instrumental talent that goes unrecognized. The appeal of great musicians transcends the usual fan base of their genres, because their playing is so good.

Check out Stanley Jordan

studio version;

He’s blind and a great guitarist

I’m pretty sure Stanley Jordan isn’t blind.

EDIT: Just to make sure people notice, this thread is more than three years old.

Doc Watson is legendary as a flatpicking guitarist. Picking starts at 1:06, hot picking starts at 3:04

Some blind blues guitarists:

Blind Lemon Jefferson

Blind Boy Fuller

Blind Blake

Blind Willie Johnson

Blind Willie McTell

Actually, perhaps part of it may have been due to mainstreaming. Back in the day, music was a HUGE thing at schools for the Blind. Musicans like the Blind Boys of Alabama and Stevie Wonder and Ray Charles were trained specificly in music. Now most blind students are mainstreamed.