Allright, first let’s wipe away the silly assertions about soccer, then let’s go back to the OP and answer it with some actual facts. (Disclaimer: any opinions here are really facts disguised as beliefs if you agree; if you don’t, the opposite will seem true )
Silly Assertion #1: Soccer is easy to play with no skill.
Patently untrue. The ‘soccer’ that is played between unskilled kids on thousands of fields Saturday mornings bears as little resemblance to real soccer as T-ball does to actual baseball. A horde of kids following a round ball around, attempting to kick it in no particular direction other than ‘forward’ (if the child doesn’t have a brain lapse and make a mistake as to which direction the team needs to go to score) is not soccer. Only Americans with their total failure to understand the sport (understandably the result of never seeing it on television) would consider it soccer.
True football (get a grip on this; we are the ONLY country in the world that doesn’t call this game football) is a game that involves a significant level of skill to make that round ball go where you want it to when you want it to. Failing to know how to do that correctly eventually frustrates the hell out of kids who aren’t coached properly at a young age. If you want an education in what is possible at a young age, go to a local soccer tournament for travelling teams and watch some Under-10 soccer.
Silly Assertion #2: Soccer is cheap.
One wishes this were true, but it ain’t. Actually, soccer is more expensive to equip a child for than most games. In American football, you usually equip a small child with one item: a football. All the rest is provided for you by the league. Baseball? Ball and glove (bats are available at batting cages and provided by the leagues). Basketball? Ball. Soccer? Ball, shinguards. To be more expensive for equipment, I’d say you have to get to hockey or golf (or tennis) among major sports.
THEN there’s the cost of the league. Here is where it really starts to get bad. Most soccer leagues require at least $30 a kid to cover basic expenses of playing, despite the fact that soccer requires less equipment than football or baseball. Yes, there are some leagues that run on shoestring budgets, but the league my kids played in was pretty typical: after shelling out $30 for each kid, there was a fund-raiser during which each was expected to raise another $30. Total expenditure per child: $60. This is NOT an inexpensive sport (sigh).
Silly Assertion #3: Women’s soccer isn’t exciting.
Stupid assertion, made by someone who doesn’t appreciate the game. No, they can’t kick it as far, they don’t kick it as hard, they don’t run as fast. They would be eaten alive by the English Premiership or the Italian Serie A. Still, they are quite skilled with the ball, they tend to eschew the stupid long-ball tactics of teams like Norway or Ireland, and it is, after all, still soccer, which on its own is quite thrilling, if you know what to look for.
Now, let’s look at the reasons to have kids play soccer:
Reason #1: It’s an equal opportunity sport.
This is perhaps the most compelling argument for choosing soccer. Unlike baseball and football, there isn’t any position on the soccer field where you can stick a less-athletic child and have him/her be out of the way. No matter whether you are playing 3 on 3 or 5-a-side or a full 11 per side, the nature of the game is that the ball will consistently end up where a given player who wants to can attempt to play it. For comparison, watch a little league right fielder some day.
In addition, unlike basketball, the vast majority of the players are on the field at any given time, usually. Most recreational youth leagues ensure this by limiting the number of players per team so that the number of substitutes is significantly less than the number of players on the field, and/or by mandating the amount of time each player must play (as an example, the American Youth Soccer Organization, or AYSO, requires every child play at least one-half of a game). Riding the pine is a rare experience for a soccer kid.
Thirdly, and unfortunately, at the early stages, most kids are equally skilled at soccer, since most kids haven’t ever played around with a soccer ball. This does NOT mean that each kid is equally talented; an athletically gifted child will run rings around the opposition with the soccer ball even before they have acquired some real skill with it. But your child will not be behind in the learning curve from the get-go (unless you live where ethnic demographics places a number of youths in your league who spent their days teething on soccer balls).
Reason #2: The sport’s rules emphasize ‘fairness’.
The rules of soccer were developed in the mid-1800’s to allow English public schools (those are private schools in our way of thinking) to teach young gentlemen how to BE young gentlemen. Now, admittedly that emphasis has been lost over the years since, but the laws still have at their root the enforcement of fairness and sportsmanship. Indeed, one of the ways you can get sent off a soccer field for the rest of the game is to commit two acts of ‘unsporting conduct’ or one act of ‘serious foul play’. Compare that to what they learn in American football… (shudder)
Reason #3: There are more opportunities for girls to play than many other sports
No one in America for the last 40 years running a youth soccer league has questioned providing an equal opportunity for girls to play. Contrast the situation in baseball, where the girls get weeded out very early and sent off to play ‘softball’, or American football, where they simply have no alternative. When I grew up in the 60’s, we had no girls basketball league; many places today still don’t. Kudos to soccer.
Soccer Myth #1: Soccer is safer.
Soccer is less injurious to youths than American football, it is true. But compared to baseball and even basketball, soccer has more injuries per 1000 participants, including troublesome ankle, knee and head injuries (and that’s not including the worries over excessive heading of the ball causing brain damage). But, let’s face it, if injuries are your concern, teach them golf.
Soccer Myth #2: Soccer isn’t popular.
Total nonsense. No, it doesn’t measure up to the big four of team sports here, but the MLS currently averages about 15,000 per game, and there are three lower leagues with something like 90 teams participating professionally, some of which manage in excess of 5,000 per game attendance.
Also, soccer IS available on the TV, you just have to hunt it down. Look for Fox Sports (either a local version like Fox Sports Detroit or the national version, Fox Sports World), which has soccer on usually without much interruption from noon Eastern to about 4 am. Also, don’t forget the spanish language channels, Univision and Telemundo. I watched all of the '82, '86 and most of the '90 World Cup Finals on Univision; you get pretty good at recognizing terms like tiro de esquina (corner kick) and sacre de banda (goal kick). And no one needs to interpret Andres Cantor yelling “GOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOL!!”
I have coached and refereed soccer for 11 years. In that time, I can say quite cheerfully that I have never seen happier faces on children as when having fun on the soccer field. Manchester United v. Arsenal it ain’t, but it’s still lots of fun.