Why would my magnetic watchband stop “working”?

I’ve had an Apple Watch with a watchband that holds together by using magnets the length of the band. Over the last couple of months, the “strength” of the band, IOW, the tightness which holds the 2 bands together has steadily decreased. It got to the point where slightly bumping my wrist would cause my watch to come off. There was no visible damage to the band. I really like the band when it works properly so I ordered another one. The new one works just like it should. It holds tightly.

How is this possible? I’ve never heard of magnets losing their effectiveness.

Amazon link for clarity.

Color me surprised.

I was so predisposed to the idea that magnets are forever (or at least close enough to it for human purposes) that it didn’t even occur to me to google it. I guess the daily “snapping” the bands together cause the magnets to weaken.

Did you change which strap lays on top of which, possibly by reversing the straps at some point? The link says that the order matters:

No. When you try it with the wrong band on top, it doesn’t work at all. It’s not like its functionality is just diminished.

Ok. The diagram just says it “will feel weak”, but I guess it’s worse than that.

Impact can make a magnet loses effectiveness, but the amount from a watch band clanging shut, especially one with a cushion, seems very unlikely to me.

Maybe the magnets are moving around inside. I don’t know how they’re contained within the strap, but conceivably they could rotate or shift in some other way over time, perhaps exacerbated by the flexing of the strap.

I remember as a kid you could buy little packs of several different magnets in the toy aisle. The horseshoe always had a little block of metal attached, but I didn’t know why until way into adulthood:

I have seen somewhere that those watchbands use flexible magnets, IOW refrigerator magnets. They are not very strong since they are a mixture of plastic and magnetic material that is not very dense and subject to demagnetization. Strong magnets may re-orient the magnetic material so it is effectively demagnetized. The material may also be low quality that loses its magnetic orientation simply from vibration and impact.

That’s a reasonable theory. It just never occurred to me that any magnets can change over time.

That’s interesting. I always just assumed that the bar was so you’d have something to play with.

Something I learned on the Dope. I knew they could demagnetize but had little understanding of how they were magnetized and demagnetized.

A lot of metals can magnetize or demagnetize. The heads of a cassette tape player could magnetize, and that was one cause of players “eating” tapes. At least, that’s what the guy at Radio Shack told me. I had a player that I took to Radio Shack once to ask why it had started eating tapes, and the manager ran what he called a “demagnetizer” over it while it was on PLAY (without a tape). Worked fine after that.

Not only that, but I discovered that a cassette player can trigger the stolen book alarm at a library. Also, if you run a cassette player through the thing that keeps books from triggering the alarm, it can erase them.

Since the books have a metal strip in the spine, I assume there’s some process of magnetizing and demagnetizing going on when they are returned and checked out.