Women's bodies and healthcare

I did not wish to further Hi-jack the new amendments thread. I will admit I’m a bit angry.
I have found that when is comes women’s rights to bodily autonomy that many on the board seem pretty content to sacrifice this right to “moderate” so that they/we (liberal/progressives) appear less scary? reasonable?

It’s an easy sacrifice right for most (probably not all but the people I was debating with in the mentioned thread) were male.
late term abortions are always a tragedy a loss. The baby is wanted and cannot survive or can kill the mother.
I’m not really interested in a debate on abortion that has been done to death. What I’m pissed about it the attitude that any reference to women’s healthcare must be “moderated” by, this thing that does not happen.

It has always been my assumption that if men had babies abortions would be offered at the drive through. I kid I don’t think that, but it really wouldn’t be such a controversial issue. All this to say women’s bodies should not be political pawns. And to the posters who insist that it’s all politics that’s what it’s all about: where has the government, the doctors, politics ever made private, intimate, incredibly painful and private medical decisions for you?

What annoys me is how most of these debates focus only on the damage done to the individual pregnant woman if abortion rights are curtailed. That ignores how it affects all women and girls living in the resultant society, how that’s going to have a direct impact on what it means to be female, and its implications for all interactions between the sexes.

Exactly. Being comfortable with “moderating” to coddle the ignorance hurts all of us. My daughter and my sister in law have both had this, “silly little woman” crap dumped on them in serious medical situations. I see it as just another logical outcome from this attitude.

Being pissed about that attitude is perfectly reasonable. I sometimes don’t know what to do when so many people accept a lie as truth.

I suspect it’s easier for a lot of people to focus on concrete examples. Like the rest of us, Mrs. Odesio isn’t getting any younger, and last year some decisions needed to be made in regards to her ability to reproduce. We live in Arkansas, and her OB/GYN wanted to know how willing I would be to sign off on some procedures. To his credit, according to Mrs. Odesio, he was unhappy to even be having that conversation with her, but because of the political climate and past experiences he felt the need to broach the subject.

I was incensed when Mrs. Odesio told me and asked, “Why the fuck does anyone need my opinion on what you want done?” Of course it was a rhetorical question and I understood why. It was the first time reproduction rights ever had an impact on me albeit indirectly. Mrs. Odesio felt pressured to make a quick decision for fear that something might be illegal next year or even within a few months. Someone was standing on her neck and it really pissed me off.

And of course women throughout the United States have had it much worse than Mrs. Odesio.

I’ve heard from women who have had a hard time (or, at the very least, found themselves in situations not unlike that Mrs. Odesio experienced) when they discussed sterilization with their doctors.

Back in 2004, I, then a 34-year-old male, asked my primary care physician about a vasectomy. He was hesitant at first; not from politics, but just because of the fact that I was still in prime child-bearing age and vasectomy reversal is expensive and painful. I asked him what my insurance company (his employer, however indirectly) would rather pay for: a vasectomy, or a pregnancy, a birth, and 18 years of childcare? He signed the referral on the spot.

I think that, for women, when a doctor asks them how sure they are when they discuss permanent or quasi-permanent sterilization, it’s not coming from a place of patriarchy. It’s about trying to make sure they fully understand what could very well be a life-changing decision.

To an extent I disagree … at least historically. I have only anecdotal experience, but it used to be routine for a doctor to question or outright refuse permanent birth control for women. It used to be pretty routine for them to need the husband’s consent. Things haven’t changed as much as many people think they have. Odesios story as one example. The pernicious lie that we need to cater to people who do not have women’s interests in mind is stupid. Allowing the lie to comfort these people will not make them go away. It will encourage them to take the next step in limiting our freedom. I know that sounds overly dramatic, but there are those who seek to control women and the first step is to dictate our medical choises.

I saw a “humorous” sign recently in a sign store:

We live in a time where intelligent people are being silenced so that stupid people won’t be offended.

It applies to one hell of a lot more than abortion. But it most certainly does apply to abortion.

I agree that most doctors (including female doctors) probably don’t intend to be coming from a place of patriarchy when they question a female patient’s desire for sterilization. But I think there’s still a lot of systemic sexism unconsciously influencing the perception of women’s choices in such matters, for a lot of people.

Undoubtedly so.

Neither the question, nor his resulting action, makes a whole lot of sense. Why would the doctor care what the insurance company had to pay for? It has no affect on him and should be irrelevant to his decision.

I think you are lacking some context here. My husband also got some gentle pushback about his vasectomy. It’s probably the worst thing a medical professional has ever done to him.

As a woman with complex reproductive health care needs, I have spent my entire life fighting the system to get the care I need. At 13 the first barrier I encountered was the doctor who didn’t take my mother seriously about my severe menstrual pain and dysphoria and how critical it was that I see an OBGYN. (My mother suffered the same, and nobody did anything about it until she (with full intent) threatened to kill herself. Same story for my Aunt.)

It’s been a fight for legitimacy every year, every interaction at every doctor, especially OBGYNs. It took me 35 years to find someone to take the PMDD seriously, even longer to diagnose intense pelvic pain. I’ve tried multiple times to get a laproscopy to diagnose endometriosis, clearly presented my family history of said disorder in a formal letter asking for medical help, and was brushed off with an ultrasound. Repeatedly I was told I couldn’t get a hysterectomy (or even a laproscopy to test for endo) because I was of childbearing age.

I have abnormal levels of several hormones, but I only found that out after the first doctor told me it wasn’t possible and declined to order a blood test.

When I was pregnant I went in for severe abdominal pain. The doctor questioned whether I was in as much pain as a claimed. She’s one of the better doctors I had. I kept her on for years.

I am now 43, staring down the horror of menopause. When they took my Aunt off the pill during menopause they made her suffer agonizing pain, heavy bleeding and severe depression for over a year before they agreed to a hysterectomy.

This is my future. I told my husband I really hope my son is in college before it starts because I don’t want him to see me like this. When I’m not on the pill it’s a living hell on earth, not just for me but everyone around me.

When I talked to my OBGYN about my menopause concerns and the symptoms I’ve been having the last few years, she recommended vitamin shakes.

The lack of respect and endless condescension women experience in the field of reproductive health care is as pervasive as it is well-documented. It is accompanied by a tremendous gap in research literature on women’s reproductive health.

Medically, women are already second class citizens. Our concerns and our suffering are routinely ignored, minimized, and projected as psychological problems. If we get too upset about the care we’re not receiving, we’re labeled as difficult and the standard of care drops even lower.

Which is why I don’t complain. I don’t think I’ve ever once complained to a medical office about the care I received, no matter how I was treated. Because I would only be treated worse.

The abortion argument, or sterilization argument, cannot be truly understood without this context. It’s an attempt to codify women’s de-facto second class medical status into law.

I’m so sorry for the way you’ve been treated and the pain you’ve had and are expecting in the near future. I think you should put your foot down and demand the care you need. Hopefully someone will get with the program.

You’ve said everything I’ve been trying to communicate here so much better than I can. My daughter recently had this sort of treatment and they could have killed or disabled her with their condescending bs. Luckily, I took her to a different ER and they took her seriously. It is possible to find good care. It shouldn’tbe such a challenge, but it’s not totally impossible … yet.

Which brings me to the point of this thread. If we continue to try and please the stupid, crazy, and the misogynistic phonies, we leave ourselves open to further eroding what little progress we’ve made in women’s healthcare, especially reproductive care, though it really isn’t limited to that. The attitude that women are a little slow and “hysterical” about their symptoms is epidemic in the healthcare industry.
Edited because paragraphs are thing.

That’s not even getting into the two women I know who had their concerns ignored for years and in both cases they had cervical cancer. One of them almost bled out in the OR.

And after the ultrasound found nothing (as I expected it wouldn’t, it’s not a gold standard diagnostic tool for endo) this woman actually had the nerve to say to me “Aren’t you relieved it isn’t anything serious?”

It is truly appalling and disgusting what women have traditionally had to endure, and still have to endure, to be taken seriously by the medical profession. The point I was trying to make is that, at least as regards permanent(ish) sterilization, men sometimes get pushback as well.

Yes, the doctor asked my husband if we had any kids, he said we have one, and we’re done.

The doctor asked, “How do you think he will feel growing up with no siblings?”

My husband was somewhat taken aback. He said, “He has lots of cousins.”

I mean damn, that’s insensitive. But it’s par for the course for parents with one kid. Some people can’t fathom it. As an only child who has always cherished my solitude, let’s just say their arguments don’t hold much water for me.

I have (only half) jokingly told the Ottlets that Mother Nature is a hoax: it’s actually Father Nature. Mother Nature would never have made Her daughters go through what they’ve been burdened with in the reproductive process.

(And it’s not just reproduction. Og only knows how many women have died because they didn’t present the same symptoms of cardiac arrest as a man, and the male symptoms are the ones that emergency responders are — or until recently, were — trained to recognize.)

As the father of daughters whom I love beyond words, I find the whole situation infuriating.

I’m not sure I understand your concern here. Doesn’t all of the harm to the individual generalize to society at large?

I have a very egalitarian partner, but once I got pregnant I realized, oh there’s actually a lot of this burden he can’t share. The physical toll of pregnancy, the injuries that occur during childbirth, the postpartum hormones, and for women who breastfeed, a year of physical sacrifice. Even the most supportive partner cannot compensate for all that. It’s a lot.

Childbirth hit me hard in a lot of ways. People asked my husband maybe three or four weeks postpartum how I was doing, he said I was still recovering. They said, “Oh? Did she have a C-section?”

Because women otherwise are just supposed to bounce back immediately I guess.

I had a vaginal delivery and it took me about 6-8 months to recover and another year before I felt like myself again and in some ways I’m permanently altered. Maybe it hit me harder because I was older (37) but when my husband’s pro-life cousin talks about women having abortions to avoid the “inconvenience” of pregnancy, I love her, but I wanna throw things at her.

I gave up two years of my life and my health to have my son - and I really wanted that kid. Asking the same of someone who doesn’t even want a child - not even to speak of what it will be like for the unwanted child - it’s too much to demand.

I knew a woman years ago who had a pair of twins (trust me she really didn’t need any more kids as she barely cared for the ones she had) and the doctor asked her what will you do if something happens to them (the kids) her comment was if something did a new child wouldn’t replace them.