Okay, it’s not often that I feel the need to comment here about a Page 2 feature, but I absolutely cannot remain silent on this one.
The subject, worst coaching decisions. Here’s the link: http://espn.go.com/page2/s/list/worstdecisions.html
I picked #4, because IMHO that one was a no-brainer. When you’re up by two scores, then you can think about padding the stats or running up the score. But when it’s just one score, and a *completely safe kneel down ends the game[/i, doing anyting else isn’t just boneheaded, it’s downright insane. This is the only one which was completely unjustifiable, so it was an easy choice.
As for the others? While I usually admire the creativity of the Page 2 staff, they were way off base on nearly all the others.
#1: Yeah, I know what happened…the Red Sox closers threw away a 3-run lead. (There may have been just one…feel free to correct.) I’m bewildered at how this almost never comes up. You’d think that the guys who <<BLEW THE SAVE>> would get some heat, but no, it’s always Buckner, Buckner, Buckner. And I don’t remember him committing any errors while the Red Sox still had a chance of winning it in the 10th.
My goodness. The ubergoats of the game getting off completely scot free. I don’t believe this crazy game sometimes.
#2: Maybe there wasn’t anyone better? Since ESPN.com hasn’t actually mentioned who Dressen shoulda picked, I’m inclined toward that view. Cal Ripken Jr. Syndrome strike again.
#3: I’ve already covered this in Week 12 Picks. My view in a nutshell: Look, I don’t care how damn questionable the call is, you’re damn professionals; MAKE THE STOP. In fact, sometimes coaches deliberately do this just to see if you really got what it takes. Hmm…on the other hand, this is the Lions we’re talking about, so maybe it was a no-brainer.
#5: Who knows. Maybe if it were just one goal, he wouldn’t have been pulled. Maybe the Soviets’ number was up, and nothing they did that day would’ve given them the win. I definitely don’t think that one man is to blame for this.
#6: Almost as baffling as forgetting all about that stupid worthless Red Sox bullpen was forgetting about, oh, Scottie Pippen, Toni Kukoc, and Horace Grant…wait, I think it was Dennis Rodman that year, who was even tougher. The reason no one ever double-teamed Jordan was because it would’ve left Pippen, or Kukoc, or maybe BJ Armstrong wide open, and since they were offensive threats as well, that wasn’t an option. Jeez, less than half a decade removed from the glory days, and everyone thinks Jordan did everything all by himself with no help. Unbelievable.
#7: Okay, I’m kinda inclined to go with this one. Except that it’s a college game between two teams with nothing to lose. Remember what I mentioned about the coach testing the players? Exactly what was happening here. Jeez, what’s next, Michael Vick getting crucified for a game-losing interception in the Pro Bowl?
#8: This would’ve been a horrible decsion. That is, if it were not the '95 Cowboys, who…I’m still extremely adamant about this…had Troy Aikman, Emmitt Smith, Michael Irvin, and a crushing offensive line, and thus should’ve been able to get one measly damn foot. Oh yeah, weren’t they able to overcome this horrible, horrible failure and win the Super Bowl? Holding this up as one of the worst coaching decisions ever is nearly as stupid as endlessly ragging Retief Goosen for three-putting from 12 feet on the final hole of the US Open THAT HE WON ANYWAY.
#9: Maybe this wasn’t the best decision, but keep in mind that these are the Vikings we’re talking about here, who have a history of finding ways to blow big games. Green was probably worried that Cunningham would throw an interception that’d be returned for a touchdown, or a field goal blocked and returned for a touchdown, or Moss would make the catch but get his bell rung and run the wrong way, then fumble into his own end zone, whereupon a Falcons defender falls on it for the touchdown. I certainly woudln’t have put money against any of these occurrences.
#10: Eh. I guess it was questionable, but let’s be serious here, the Pacers were not winning the championship. Because they never win the championship. Kinda like the Cardinals.
Fire at will, sports fans.