Just one. I’ll go first: The Sting.
Some have touched on it in his RIP thread ➜ RIP Robert Redford ■ .
What’s yours?
Ordinary People
As I said in that thread, The Sting, but he is one part of a large ensemble cast. I’m not sure how much credit to give him for the greatness of the movie.
He was an iconic actor but I’m not sure if he was a great actor. Paul Newman, he was a great actor.
Botch Casually And The Somedunce Kid (I may have the spelling wrong 
)
Butch and Sundance barely nudges out Sneakers.
All the President’s Men
He made so many good movies but my favorite performance is in The Candidate:
Stranger
He was terrific in Three Days Of The Condor.
This would be my answer too, only Redford doesn’t appear in it. For a movie that stars Redford, I would pick Butch Cassidy and the Sundance Kid.
Same - though I also really enjoy Spy Game and Last Castle.
Username does not check out.
Spy Game
I recall the one Mad parody being called The Way We Bore.
Being a baseball fan has to be The Natural.
Jeremiah Johnson followed closely by Three Days of the Condor.
Another vote for Jeremiah Johnson. A truely intense man’s movie.
Og help me, I’ve only seen the social-media-reaction meme (Redford as Johnson, nodding his head in approval).
My favorite is Sneakers though his work with Newman is exemplary.
I would pick Butch Cassidy and the Sundance Kid. I’m a sucker for cowboy outlaw movies of any stripe.
The Sting, all the way.
And I know it’s pick only one, but after that it’s The Natural, then The Great Waldo Pepper.
J.J. for sure.
Not just a man’s movie. It’s essentially a love story.