This was a hypothetical I had with 2 friends. 1 female, 1 male.
The male friend said that he would take her (Katy Perry) out for fishbowl margaritas, and a walk by the Riverfront.
I, also male, said that I would make her (Natalie Portman) dinner (homemade sushi) and then a late night excursion to the zoo.
The girl thought for a good 30 seconds and shrugged. She said “Maybe something like archery?” I asked her why. She said “Well, because I’ve never done it and I wanted to try it.”
Now, the topic of whether or not girls know how to set up dates is an OP for a different time. I ask the SDMB who their celeb crush would be and how they utilize their one shot to charm the pants off them.
(the girl’s crush was Jake Gyllenhall. ::shrug: