[QUOTE=silenus]
[QUOTE=FOX News]
Last week, the Supreme Court ruled in its 5-4 decision in the case of Hudson v. Michigan that when police conduct an illegal, no-knock raid, any evidence they seize in the raid can still be used against the suspect at trial, even though the raid was conducted illegally.
[/QUOTE]
[/QUOTE]
I guess what gets me is that poor **Silenus ** was misled by the slanted description of the case (by . . . Fox News). **Silenus ** is a smart guy. I’m surprised he didn’t read the opinion himself.
On the one hand the lead at least discloses that it is the exclusion of evidence that is at stake here. But it fails to point out that the police had a warrant in Hudson. In fact, the word warrant appears only once in the article.
Also amazingly slanted is the author’s description of the holding in *Wilson * and generally misstatement the castle doctrine. I can’t say I’m surprised, or even disappointed. I’ve come to expect such things from this source. Normally I only consult Fox for entertainment. Allow me to illustrate briefly.
[QUOTE=Fox]
It is grounded in the “Castle Doctrine,” which states that a man’s home is his castle, his place of asylum, and he has the right to defend it against intruders who would do him harm.
[/QUOTE]
Sort of
[QUOTE=Wilson]
Although the common law generally protected a man’s house as “his castle of defence and asylum,” 3 W. Blackstone, Commentaries *288 (hereinafter Blackstone), common-law courts long have held that “when the King is party, the sheriff (if the doors be not open) may break the party’s house, either to arrest him, or to do other execution of the K[ing]'s process, if otherwise he cannot enter.” Semayne’s Case, 5 Co. Rep. 91a, 91b, 77 Eng. Rep. 194, 195 (K. B. 1603). To this rule, however, common-law courts appended an important qualification:
[/QUOTE]
(Emphasis added.)
Like I said, the knock-and-announce rule protects your door–that’s it.
[QUOTE=Fox]
the Court ruled in the case of Wilson v. Arkansas that the centuries-old common law notion that police should announce themselves before entering a private home was engrained in the Fourth Amendment. That is, it is an inherent part of the Constitution.
[/QUOTE]
Interesting . . . According to the Court
[QUOTE=Wilson]
we hold that in some circumstances an officer’s unannounced entry into a home might be unreasonable under the Fourth Amendment.
[/QUOTE]
I’m not interested in doing a sentence by sentence rebuttal of the author’s “research,” other than to point out that I doubt he did much. But let’s take a look at one more thing:
(Emphasis added.)
I’ll concede that more illegal no-knock raids and more unneccessary deaths are both possibilities. If that’s the case, it’s a bad thing. Of course states are free to pass their own rules about this, and *Wilson * notes that some have. Similarly, Hudson cites several federal statutes imposing similar rules.
But I fail to see how a no-knock rule will lead to more mistaken raids on innocent people. It’s definitely not certain that this will occur. In these cases, *Hudson * and the one cited by the author, law enforcement personnel had a warrant. Cops with a warrant are going to search. Moreover,
[QUOTE=Wilson]
Finally, courts have indicated that unannounced entry may be justified where police officers have reason to believe that evidence would likely be destroyed if advance notice were given.
[/QUOTE]
(citing Ker).
I suspect that in the case the author cites (they thought there was a meth lab there), a court would excuse an unannounced entry. In other words, the entry in that case might not even have been “illegal.”
Silenus, it’s not too early to call it a police state–it’s a little late. But what the hell: Go for it.