Your Worst Ever Meal

OK, this is kind of gross.

Five years ago I came down with a near-fatal case of pneumonia and spent over a week in hospital. I had a cup at my bedside for all the phlegm I was coughing up - I’d say by about the fourth day there was at least a quart of it.

On about the fifth day, the food they served me included a bowl of mushroom soup, which looked *exactly like … *

I think I managed to swallow about a spoonful and a half of it before getting ill. And I still won’t touch mushroom soup to this day.

School. Wiener sauce. Well, this is more likely amongst the category of “Meals not eaten”, but I could never eat but a tiny notch of it - and that was an effort in itself. The smell was worst part of it. Once I covered my nose in effort to avoid the smell, and teacher said I should stop kidding around. I wasn’t kidding - the smell really was that bad. I still can’t understand how they have managed to turn a simple food that bad. Damned be Finnish free school lunches.

For homecooking, off the top of my head, I can’t think of anything that can top some of what I’ve just read. (fried clam chowder? Mir…Mir…Miracle whip potatoes? And how the hell do you fuck up Jello??) hahhaha.

For ordering, I was in a small town once travelling through on business and was directed to Ethel’s Diner (or something like that) for the greatest steak special around. It was a grisly hamburger patty about the size of a McDonalds burger, a side of brown collard greens and a salad served in one of those 3" diameter styrofoam bowls with a foil packet of french dressing on top. All this for 7.95. (The locals in the place were all eating it with gusto). The perks of So. IL.

The worst thing I never ate, I cooked myself. Had a strange and irresistable urge for some beef heart. That isn’t the problem. The problem is that a few weeks earlier I had just bought a complete cast iron set and had been seasoning them. In the dutch oven however, I used too much oil and didn’t get around to wiping it out. I assumed that my wife had used it and the oil in it was fresh. So I started cooking the heart in it for a delectable stew. The oil was in fact, quite rancid and when I was about to dish myself up some grub, my wife came home and started shrieking about an ungodly stench in the house, which was my lunch. (One of the downfalls of having no sense of smell). The dutch oven turned into a flower pot that evening.

My worst meal would actually be quite excellent for people who like it. This happened when I was just hired at my first job out of college. My boss and I were going to Italy to meet with a Very Important Client. For some reason, we had different flights, and I arrived in Italy before she did. Her flight was delayed, and I received a message that I would have to do the dinner meeting with the VIC by myself, along with about a bajillion warnings that I was to do whatever it would take to keep said VIC happy.

VIC takes me to one of the best restaurants in Florence, and insists upon ordering for both of us. First up: slimy mushrooms. I hate mushrooms. These were big honking portions of mushrooms, and so I put on my game face and choked down every bite. Next was steak. I love steak. This steak was served with a very hot peppercorn sauce. I love hot peppercorn sauce. The problem: I had oral surgery the week before, and every last peppercorn ended up … well, I don’t want to get into the medical specifics here, because it’s kind of gross, but let’s just say peppercorns were falling out of my mouth for the next week. And it hurt, btw, but I kept smiling and chatting up the VIC. Dessert was icky by anyone’s standards (I think). I’ve never seen it anywhere else in Tuscany, so it must have been a speciality of the house. A cake, like a fruit cake, but made with veggies. Veggie cake. Cold. Covered in aspic. The color of snot. It jiggled in a menacing way. It had a skin on top, like cocoa gets, so I delicately peeled off the skin and took a nibble of the cold aspicy cake. “But the skin is the best part*!” exclaimed the VIC.

I went back to the hotel and cried while I excavated peppercorns from my gums.

Of course now I would have a million ways to gently and politely order my own dinner, but at the time, I was 22, first job, first “solo” meeting with a big client … can you say pressure? I want my “Clean Plate Club” badge now, please.

I haven’t been in “The Magic City” for 30 years but it looks like the (you should pardon the expression) cuisine hasn’t improved any. My favorite was “Authetic Italian Spaghetti”: Hunt’s Tomato Sauce straight out of the can onto lukewarm spaghetti and stuck under the broiler to heat up. “Do you have any parmesan cheese?” “What’s that?”

You don’t even want to know about the “New England Clam Chowder”. (shudder)

To be expected, I guess, from people who have Eleventy Zillion acres of flat ground to work with and build the town in a gully so it can get flushed down the river every Spring.

17 months at Minot AFB…the longest 5 years of my life.

Sweet mother of God! There’s no way I’d have been able to eat that. No, thankfully this stuff was pure white lumpy crap. No green, snot, or orangish-brown colors to make it even worse.

–Tim

Strangely, most of my bad meals have been made by cooking professionals - as in my relative, the caterer, and the family friend, the caterer. I always wonder who pays these people to cook for them? and why?

Anyway, the absolute worst meal, my sister and I and two friends of ours planned on having a nice meal out. We were all college students with limited college student budgets, but we decided to go to somewhere nice. Sister had walked by a restaurant several times while running errands at the place she was working. So we went.

The place was big enough to hold two tables and the very loud, five piece jazz band in the corner. We couldn’t enjoy conversation across the table, because we couldn’t hear across the table. The band was close enough to touch, and all of them were playing at full volumen. The place was more expensive than we’d anticipated, but my sister thought it had to be good, and convinced us all to not find a cheaper, less scary place to eat. we decided to splurge just this one time. We shouted back and forth for a while, but eventually, our throats started hurting so conversation died. We shouted our orders at the waiter (who shouted back at us) and eventually the food came.

Everyone’s food was various and very rich (kind of pretty, in fact) colors of brown. Despite the fact we’d all ordered different things, no one could tell by looking that there was any difference between entrees. Everyone’s food was some kind of overspiced horror - completely inedible. At first, we kept trying to attack it - we were young, the food was expensive, we assumed that it must be our fault (inexperienced palates or whatever) that we didn’t like the food - and that sooner or later the richness would shine through. It didn’t. And we were starting to get a massive headache from the BAND THAT JUST KEPT ON PLAYING. Eventually, one of the friends gave up and said “I can’t eat this, take it away.” Stupidly, the rest of us failed to do the same. And even had the crap boxed up to take home claiming we were “full.” We then paid for the overpriced food (except the one stunningly brilliant friend) and left, never to return.

Not only the worst meal I’ve ever eaten, but still - 6 years (and huge salary increases) later the most expensive.

I don’t know if this is as bad as some of yours, but here it is:

Last summer, a friend had a party, and Mr. Jeannie and I were unable to attend. The next day, we went over to her house to play board games and have leftovers from the party. On the menu was tacos.

The hard shells were stale. Okay, I can live with that. The lettuce was turning a little brown. Fine, I’ll pick out the good stuff. There was no sour cream, as she had mistakenly bought cream cheese instead. Fine, my friend isn’t a rocket scientist. I’ll live. However, the meat…oh, how to describe the meat. It was beef, at least as far as we could tell. But it hadn’t been flavored with anything (she didn’t know taco meat should be flavored). But it tasted like it had been boiled. I was reminded of that scene in “Better Off Dead” when the mom boiled bacon so it would be healthier.

Overall, that was one disgusting freakin’ taco. I only could choke down one, making the excuse that I had just eaten and wasn’t too hungry (actually, I was starving). Mr. Jeannie managed to eat two of those things. When she brought out the chili-cheese dip later, we downed the entire bowlful with a bag of tortilla chips because we were so hungry (and the dip was delicious).

I’m not going into details here, for which you should all be thankful, but I’ll say this much: It was airplane food. On an English airline. The horror… the horror…

Not really a meal but…
My father used to hunt. One day I come home from school and he’s roasted some unidentifable piece of meat. He asks me to try some.
It’s horrible-tough and gamy. I as him what it is. He says…

wait for it

Raccoon.

And my family wonders why I don’t eat red meat anymore.

My mother-in-law has an amazing talent for food. Really.

Her way of making chicken and dumplings is to broil the chicken in a pan on the stove, make the dumpling mix, then drop the balls of flour into the pan and cook until it’s time to eat.

But one memorable occasion was when she served pasta. She brought the covered bowl to the table and lifted it with a flourish. The shells were swimming in a brown sauce and were rather large, ribbed and curled underneath.

They looked like large blanched slugs in brown sauce.

Across the table, my wife saw the look of horror spread across my face and she started to laugh (she’s had a lifetime of this kind of cooking). When I told her later my name for the dish, she couldn’t wait to tell her mother, who took it with rather good grace.

My worst cooking experience has to be from using James Beard’s recipe for Irish Soda Bread in “Beard on Bread.” It either turns out wonderful or ends up as a doorstop. But my personal worst has to be the Tibetan Prayer Wheel recipe from the La Leche League cookbook. It used an incredible array of healthy ingredient, came out weighing six pounds, was thoroughly inedible and fed the compost heap still warm from the oven.

On a family trip to Toronto many suns ago, we stopped for breakfast at a greasy spoon just outside our hotel. The French toast tasted like a combination of hamburgers and pork chops - I theorize that they used the vat of grease left over from the previous night’s meals to fry up the French toast.

Later in the day, my dad realized he’d forgotten his hat in aforesaid restaurant. Mom says, “Well, that place was pretty near the hotel, so we can just stop there tomorrow morning on the way out.” And my dad replied, “Uh, I think I’ll just buy a new hat.” This from a man who ate shredded wheat - the big ones - for breakfast every morning for thirty years.

I can tell you the worst thing I have ever seen someone else eat. (I’m not sure I can manage this w/out using obscenities.)

My friend ordered this…this THING from a guess-the-middle-eastern-country-to-which-it-aspires hole in the wall. It had one of those leg-of-giant-animal rotisseries, and I swear to God some of the meat had a green tint. That which my friend ordered seemed like a meaty spring roll. The “sauce” with which it was filled smelled and looked like melted plastic. It was reprehensible. It was disgusting. I started gagging just looking at it; my stomach tried to crawl out of my mouth. My friend took one bite and began to vomit in the street. I am getting nauseated just thinking about it. If the Pope ever had to eat that food, he would renounce any belief in God. Starving people would wave it away in an offended manner. I am completely certain that if he had forced himself to eat the thing (which, as we had no Thorazine or pure capsacin, would have been impossible), he would have died right there in the street.

(This “”"“restaurant”""" was on one of those torn-up streets near the Leidseplein in Amsterdam. IT WAS SO FOUL. I staggered out of the tourist district and paid twice what I normally would for a meal just so that I didn’t have to think about the gut-wrenching SHIT I had just witnessed.) Anyway. Have a nice day.

I’ve been lurking for weeks, waiting for this exact thread!

Many moons ago, but not enough moons unfortunately- I was invited to thanksgiving dinner at the house of my incredibly hot girlfriend’s grandmother. I would have eaten ground glass topped with pureed poodle poop if my woman had asked me, but what I ended up eating was far, far worse.

Her grandmother prepared a turkey that had been frozen in a platic bag, an OPEN plastic bag for about 6 months in a semi-functional freezer. She cooked said salmonella vector in an oven that wouldn’t close because the bird was too big. We were treated to stuffing with the consistency and flavor of regurgitated chum, with the obligatory overcooked veggies on the side. The piece de resistance (very vigorous resistance on my part) was a pizza made with an undercooked crust and hunt’s ketchup as the sauce, with american cheese.

I am the kind of guy who eats and eats and eats at thanksgiving but this year I went home hungry. Oh yeah! I forgot the green jello with mystery fruit topped with runny whipped cream. I’ve never even DREAMT of anything worse than this meal-not even the erotic nightmares starring an olive oil soaked Rosanne chasing me while riding a pig and waving her panties above her head like a lasso. Just remembering it has me gagging (I mean the meal).

Sand stew (spilled onto and then eaten off a beach).

One of the few regrets in my life is that I grew up during the casserole era.

If anyone in my neighbourhood was physically or emotionally under the weather, the ladies of the IODE (Independent Order of Daughters of the Empire) would arrive with casseroles. Lots of casseroles.

It really put the fear of, well, the fear of casseroles in us. My dad, for example, was never known to ever have been ill in all his years of marriage. Why? Fear of casserole delivery. He knew in the depths of his soul that if he were ever too weak to make it in to work, the good administrations of the IODE casseroles would finish him off.

My mother, who gave up a high end corporate career to be a housewife, got it in her head that she too should make casseroles. Her head, however, was far too filled with more interesting and worthwhile thoughts than mundane matters such as keeping an eye on the oven. In short, kitchen fires were common. She placed casserole after casserole in front of our family, and always asked my father, “Do you like it, Dear?” Being smarter than the average bear, he always answered, “Yes. Thank you.” My mother, however, being smarter than my father, knew that he was lying, and would call him on it.

A word about my parents. My mother’s father, a regional head of a provincial power commission, was illiterate, so she handled all his paperwork from the time she was in public school. After earning a couple of business degrees, she made a name for herself in the corporate world before throwing it all away to have a husband and family. Although she was a truly brilliant person, she had absolutely no training or interest in cooking. Her first meal in married life was an attempt at baked beans, in which she and my father narrowly escaped injury, for no one told her about the importance of opening the can before baking. Unfortunately, despite monumental culinary incompetence which routinely led to illness and injury, she insisted on playing the role of housewife, and therefore always having food (I use that term loosely) on the table for the family.

My father was a gentleman from a long line of gentlemen. He was always polite and considerate. He did not understand why my mother gave up business for the kitchen, for she had established herself in the corporate world and they did not have children at the time. He did not understand why she had to be the one to prepare meals, for having lived on his own for many years, he quite enjoyed cooking. Not only that, but he was a good cook, so he did not understand why casseroles were considered food. The man had grace and decorum, and was always courteous, no matter how despairing the situation.

The poor fellow’s only relief came on evenings when my mother was out with the IODE doing whatever nefarious and charitable things such organizations do. Of course she always left a casserole, and always made a point of asking the next day why it had not been eaten, but at least for the occasional evening my father, sister and I would escape the dreaded casserole.

In later years, I asked my parents about the homemaking arrangement they had. My mother told me that she was heavily influenced by society’s standards, which in her day meant that to be a successful person, a woman had to be a housewife, and pour her creativity and time into her family. Fortunately, as far as parenting skills went, she and my father were both fantastic, so all worked out just fine in the long run. It’s just that whoever decided that women should stay at home and prepare casseroles never met my mother.
What can I say. My sister and I are both feminists and vegetarians. We survived the casserole era.

Unbenknownst to me, my sister (who lurks here, but doesn’t post) read my post above about my mother’s horrificly bad mashed potatoes a la Miracle Whip. We both had a good laugh about it (she recalls it as vividly as I), and then she casually mentions that she’d told my Mom about it. :eek:

So, my Mom is at my place over the weekend, and we had a conversation that went something like this:

Mom: So, Sister tells me that you posted to the whole world about my mashed potatoes. <pouting>
Jadis: Ummm…yes. I had to…they were horrible, and it was pretty funny.
Mom: <whining> But I had to do something!! I didn’t have any butter!!!
Jadis: <collapses into a fit of giggles and is utterly unable to apologize>

She may never forgive me. If you run into her on the street, try not to bring it up. She’s traumatized enough. :smiley:

Some writer has commented that his mother was a bad a cook as it was possible to be without being actually dangerous.

Like Spiny Norman, I have had my fair share of C-Rations. C-Rations, however, are not real food. At best, they are sustenance. C-Rations are what you eat when your only alternative is roots and tree bark. If the choice is between “eggs and pork” (sometimes called “baby shit”), the hands down decision is to go with the tree bark. Old soldiers always kept a couple cans of commercial beef stew in their gas mask bag for culinary emergencies. MREs are a marginal improvement.

Years and years ago when Mrs. Gelding and your correspondent were living in Europe courtesy of the US taxpayers, we took a trip into France to see the chateaus. Except for French drivers the trip was relatively free of perils until we stopped at a country cafe for our one full meal of the day. Since we were not particularly well heeled we tended to chose a small local place and order from the fix price menu. Even though Mrs. G. had a pretty decent grasp of the language, there was nothing on the chalk board that looked familiar except one item that was clearly pork of some sort. How could we go wrong, we thought. We ordered and got…two plates of cold tripe. This was not figurative or metaphorical tripe. It was real trip, two lengths of glistening large intestine donated by a deceased hog and stuffed with lard and fragments of the donor’s snout and ears. One bite was enough to convince us both to send it back and reorder from the full menu, the cost be damned. The second meal was pretty good.

When we first moved to rural Iowa, someone paid a bill with half a pig. The animal was delivered to a local locker and the other guy and I split the meat and the locker bill. My mistake was, when asked if I wanted smoked or fresh bacon, to order it half and half. The smoked bacon was great but the fresh bacon was a new experience. Fresh bacon is what our hardy forbearers called sow belly. It is the layer of fat lying between the pig’s skin and ribs. It fries down to a pool of hot grease with a few fragments of flesh floating around in it. Fresh bacon is an acquired taste. The dog has not yet acquired a taste. I’m not even going to try.

It was far worse then you could imagine…I will be seeing the yellow shade of the mayonnaise in my nightmares for years to come…

Keith

I feel compelled to un-lurk to share this story…

The other day, my mother made meatloaf. Not too nasty by itself, but this time she used Heinz green ketchup instead of the regular kind. I fed my slice of it to my cat since I just couldn’t bear to eat something that looked like a scorched Grinch.