You're super-powered. Do you prevent the legal execution of an innocent man?

The usual fantasy contrivances give you Kryptonian-type superpowerswith no apparent weaknesses. (For those who care about such silly things, let’s say they’re at post-Crisis levels, so there’s no FTL or time-travel abilities in the mix.) You don’t have any super-tech, and as far as you know, you’re the only person so empowered. Maybe you decide to become an out & out super-hero, maybe not; that’s your call.

Anywoo … one day you become aware of a potential miscarriage of justice. An acquaintance from high school tracks you down and tells you his/her son is on death row for a murder he didn’t commit. The son is set to be executed in a few days, and the acquaintance asks for your help.

Whether from heroism, boredom, or the thirst for celebrity, you decide to investigate. In the course of a weekend (you’ve got super-speed and senses, after all) you uncover evidence that convinces you your friend’s son is innocent of the charges against him. Armed with this evidence you explore the legal options to free the accused…only to find none. It’s a state crime, so the president has no jurisdiction. The state governor hasn’t the authority to pardon the accused unilaterally, considers even a delay political suicide, and says he isn’t convinced by your evidence anyway; the parole board refuses for similar reasons, and all appeals have already been exhausted. By the time you establish all this, less than an hour remains before the accused gets the needle.

Granted that only immediate, forceful, comic-book action will save the guy’s life, what do you do?

I’d save him, then go back and explain why. Being invulnerable without the asterisk means I can afford to filibuster.

What if you were only Nigh-invulnerable?

It seems obviously the right thing to do (although you’d probably do MORE good building infrastructure in Africa or ending wars, etc). It might be prudent to establish several different super identities which are perceived different ways, so you can have a “vigilante” persona who looks more like Batman than Superman to do things like this without establishing a precedent that future supermen should do them at will.

Assuming you’re sufficiently popular, and have convincing evidence, surely it would be political suicide to execute someone, if you’re hours away from proving they’re innocent on international television?

In fact, depending what the evidence is, you should maybe consider that you’re wrong (superman was super-responsible, but it’s not clear that you are).

OTOH, maybe the situation is that you’re not trusted, and vigilaneism will just make matters worse, or that there’s a reason you can’t tell anyone how you obtained the evidence. I think, by default, “not killing innocent people” wins, but if there’s some reason you’re really sure it will change the country for the worse, you may want to consider not doing so.

I was too confused by all those options. Yes, No, or Dunno, would have been perfectly adequate.

I’d be happy assuming a superhero identity to do this, but I’d hire someone like Bob Kane to come up with the identity. I’d just make myself look like a dork. Who wants to be rescued by a dork?

Seems like this thread should tie in well with the nearby thread about jury nullification.

BTW, yes there was an episode of the TV Superman show (the George Reeves vintage) that sort-of dealt with this – only in that case, Superman convinced the guv to issue a pardon, which Superman had to get to the electric chair chamber like real fast because there were only minutes to spare.

I recall that one, and an animated Superman in which he did the same thing. But that’s not quite the issue, as in neither case was Superman necessarily acting outside the law; presumably in both cases the governor ortdered him to get his ass to the prison and stop the execution, smashing the electric chair if need be. In the OP scenario, you’re choosing between obeying the law & allowing the execution of the man you believe innocent, or saving the man while highlighting the fact that the government exists only at your sufferance.

Ummm…I think Skald’s penultimate paragraph incorrectly spells out my methodology.


As **Skald **specified, I decide to investigate for whatever reason. This means I have a shadow of a doubt that he’s guilty (or an inkling of a belief that he’s not guilty) or there’s reasonable suspicion that someone else is the actual culprit. Since the imprisonment and execution might actually be a false front for an attack on the son’s parent (my friend) or on the unblemished record of the Texas parole board or on the stellar image of the governor’s office, I take a bold move and use my superpowers to break the kid out of prison before I start my investigation - no penile party for the penal partiers this weekend! I make a point of doing so without violence and with minimal damage to property.

While MyFriend Junior is comfortably on ice in my south pole fortress/study/conservatory I go investigate and come up with the results specified by Skald. I go and catch the real murderer (or dig him up or whatever).

I wait an extra day or week past the execution date. Governor ReElectMe doesn’t lose face for the delay because everyone knows the kid was broken out but nobody knows exactly who did it or why.

I bring my friend’s son back to Texas - specifically back to a stadium during a major sports event – covered head-to-toe in protective gear just in case there are too many dozens of people at the game exercising their concealed-carry rights with loaded pistols packed in their beer coolers. I apologize to the crowd for interrupting their halftime show (or 7th inning stretch or whatever) and announce to the fans and the broadcast cameras that the real murderer is WhatsHisName, here is a copy of the evidence papers, and MyFriend Junior standing next to me didn’t do it. I hand the evidence to a reporter for a nation-wide news corporation with a good reputation (and possibly extra copies to local news stations), repeat my apologies for the interruption, promise to deliver WhatsHisName to the local police once I decide which field station is most appropriate, and fly away with MyFriend Junior.

I give the pundits time to review the evidence during their TV appearances, then deliver WhatsHisName and another copy of the evidence to a small police substation which has a holding cell but usually doesn’t get much traffic, making sure I do it at a time when the place won’t be swamped with camera crews and/or lynch mobs.


On the other hand, if I’m absolutely stuck with the conditions of the Rhymer’s penultimate paragraph…well, I’ll create a second post for detailing that plan of action.

—G!

…Just like
Watchin’ the Detectives
. --Elvis Costello
. Watching the Detectives
. My Aim is True

“I’d never have the problem because I’d be too busy fucking groupies to do any heroic crap.”

Not exactly, but probably the closest. Oh, I would do some heroic crap, but I’d keep most of it on the down-low. I don’t even know if I’d have groupies, because I’d tell very very few people about my powers.

That is the Superman dilemna - every time he’s eating a cheeseburger or chasing after one of the L girls someone needs his help that he’s not helping.

Basically I’d never have been an out-and-out superhero in the first place. FAME sounds awful.

Bear in mind that the OP doesn’t require that you be a full-time or overt superhero in the first place. Your high school friend may have witnessed the terrifying incident with the radioactive Arcturan mongoose that granted you your powers and thus be one of the few people who know you can juggle aircraft carriers and see through Taye Diggs’s pantaloons at will. In fact I think the OP makes a little more sense (to the minor extent that it makes sense at all :wink: ) if you’re not a known super-hero. In the Superman episodes mentioned above, Martha & Jon’s boy got the response he did because he had a public reputation for extreme probity (and maybe because, in the back of his mind, the governor was thinking, “Do not annoy the demigod”).

Yes. I would also like to prevent the executions of guilty men around the world, to the extent that I am able, and return them to their jail cells. However, I’d probably become overwhelmed by local crime alone. And, since no hero can save everybody from everything, I’d rather save the innocent than the guilty.

The power of a lone hero, almost no matter how super, is trivial compared to the power of the press. You’ve gathered the evidence, so if the governor isn’t convinced, you give copies to the relevant papers. ‘Governor refuses to exhonorate innocent man!’ isn’t going to help his chances of re-election.

This isn’t even remotely a hard decision. Of course I save the guy.

Still for the DP, though.

Pretty much this. As a side note, I’d try not to hurt any of the guards or other prisoners during the rescue.

Superman powers?

Super-hypnotism. Govenor pardons and damn the consequences.

Alternately, stage a breakout so that it looks like a mundane assisted and keep him on ice until I can get the media on board with the alternate perpetrator angle.

I recall that one, and an animated Superman in which he did the same thing. But that’s not quite the issue, as in neither case was Superman necessarily acting outside the law; presumably in both cases the governor ortdered him to get his ass to the prison and stop the execution, smashing the electric chair if need be. In the OP scenario, you’re choosing between obeying the law & allowing the execution of the man you believe innocent, or saving the man while highlighting the fact that the government exists only at your sufferance.
[/QUOTE]

Animation and George Reeves aside, it’s also the debut adventure from Superman’s first-ever comic-book appearance back in the '30s: shrugging off pistol fire upon breaking into the Governor’s bedroom just before the stroke of midnight, supplying the guy with last-minute evidence in time for a hastily telephoned pardon.

(Interestingly, they indirectly highlight the point in question: “This is illegal entry,” he’s told, after smashing his way in; “I’ll have you arrested!” And, after dashing off: “Thank heaven he’s apparently on the side of law and order!”)

How super-hypnotic can your power be?

No limit? Convince his jailers to let him walk out, convince the cops, prosecutors, and family of the victim that he died in a tragic accident, and make the innocent guy forget the whole thing.

Oh yeah, while I’m at it I’ll just convince the killer to walk off a cliff.

Okay, so if I’m absolutely stuck with the conditions of the Rhymer’s penultimate paragraph, I’ll borrow from an old folk tale I read in elementary school. All of these efforts, of course, are buying me time while I thoroughly investigate the situation and incontrovertibly document my findings.

I’m assuming that, being the celebrity superhero that Clark and his kin tend to be (when not in disguise), I have enough prestige to be able to ask Governor ReElectMe and/or the execution team if I can be present at the execution time and they’ll grant me my strange wish. I’m also assuming that I have access to any number of limited-use or one-off superpowers that seem strange but useful for the episode/issue at the time. We’ve seen at least two other threads and a website devoted to the odd powers and explanations my cousin Clark uses, and I’ve got a couple of my own.

~ ~~ ~~ ~~ ~~ ~

After the executioner inserts the needle that connects to the capital poison, I will use my super heat vision, focused through a pair of eyeglasses to weaken the rubber gaskets on the syringes so that, when they’re depressed, the plungers are unable to send fluid through the intravenous delivery tube. (I may have to remotely melt the interior of the tube itself, as well, to thoroughly block the flow of fluid into MyFriend Junior’s body.:smiley:

Due to an equipment malfunction, the execution will be rescheduled and an alternate method will be chosen.

During the interim, I will deliver my evidence to Governor ReElectMe. He will thank me and promise to read it, then watch me leave, then dump my paperwork into an incinerator – fueling the device for several hours.

I will ask to be present at the public hanging, as well. Naturally, my request will be granted, along with the requests of several dozen news reporters (dozens more than usually cover these events) because a second attempt at an execution is a rare and newsworthy event in and of itself.

When the executioner grabs the handle, I will remotely super-magnetize the nails on the trap door and the nails on the platform that surround the trapdoor. The trapdoor will not fall and, therefore, MyFriend Junior will not plunge through the hole and have his neck snapped.:slight_smile:

Due to an equipment malfunction, the execution will be rescheduled and an alternate method will be chosen.

During the interim, I will deliver my evidence to Federal Authorities. They will thank me and promise to read it, then watch me leave, then dump my paperwork into an incinerator – fueling the device for several hours.

I will ask to be present at the beheading, as well. Naturally, my request will be granted, along with the requests of several scores of news reporters because a third attempt at an execution is an extremely rare and very newsworthy event in and of itself.

I will visit MyFriend Junior immediately before the execution date, making sure we both smile at the cameras during our interview, making sure he insists on his innocence, and making sure I’m seen shaking the condemned man’s hand as the session ends. With that touch, I’ll convey my own impenetrable skin power to my friend’s son.

The blade will fall, yet fail to cut through the condemned man’s neck. Repeated attempts will only chip the sharpened edge.:dubious:

Due to an equipment malfunction, the execution will be rescheduled and an alternate method will be chosen.

During the interim, I will personally hand my evidence to the President of the United States. He will look me straight in the eye and, without any discernable emotion whatsoever, tell me that it’s a State’s matter and he is therefore powerless to intervene.

I will ask to be present at the firing squad, as well. Naturally, my request will be granted, along with the requests of several hundred news reporters because a fourth attempt at an execution is an unheard of and very newsworthy event around the world.

The night before the execution, I will sneak in and replace the standard issue bullets with Wolf ammunition, disguising the cartridges to look like standard-issue rounds, of course. I will also drive a brass spike into the top of the prisoner’s post, and put a chunk of Neodymium on top of the spike. At sunrise the next morning, MyFriend Junior will be offered a cigarette, blindfolded, and tied to the post. When the executioner yells AIM! I will remotely super-hyper-ultra-magnetize the Neodymium chunk. When the squad responds to “FIRE!” the steel-cored bullets will be pulled sharply upward and past the condemned man. Any shots that somehow end up hitting him will meet his impenetrable skin.:rolleyes:

Due to an equipment malfunction, the execution will be rescheduled and an alternate method will be chosen.

During the interim, I will offer my evidence to a session of the United Nations. They will all look at me and laugh. Somebody with a bit of kindness will remind me that the UN is unable to intercede in the routine proceedings of courts martial or domestic penal systems. I will hand my evidence to a reporter for Human Rights Watch International. They will publish a special edition about the matter and, like their regular editions, it will go unnoticed by anybody with any influence in the world.

I will ask to be present at the electrocution, as well. Naturally, my request will be granted, along with the requests of several thousand news reporters from around the world, all of whom got tips about the matter from friends who work in facilities and operations at the UN accommodations in New York.

As MyFriend Junior is being strapped in, I will interrupt the proceedings and say, “I don’t know what divine powers you believe in, but whichever one of them controls justice certainly seems to believe in this man. You’ve tried five times to kill him and you have failed every time. It’s time to take a good look at my evidence and realize it was TheRealCulprit who did it and not MyFriend Junior.” Then I will dramatically pull TheRealCulprit into the cameras’ view and tell the presiding authorities to take him/her away.

Epilogue:
During the commutation celebration party MyFriend Junior will discover he is severely allergic to alcohol when someone urges him to toast with champagne. Thoroughly inebriated after just one glass, he’ll stagger swiftly to the restroom, slip on a wet tile, pitch headlong into a stall, smack his head on a porcelain rim, and drown in a pool of fresh water, eucalyptus, and blue bleach. Superpowers were unable to prevent such a calamity.:smack:

—G!

Justice is one thing.
Karma? Now that is something else entirely.:eek:

Capital punishment being wrong, always, and everywhere, I would have already visited my will upon the uncivilized states of the world, and removed their ability to carry it out.

Also, extra maple syrup and bacon.