This didn’t play out as offensively as it sounds. This was as sick joke that I never thought in a million years we would be able to pull off and that is part of the reason I went along with it.
My senior year of high school, I had a friend who a continuous on-again, off-again relationship with his girlfriend. I was friends with his girlfriend too although I never thought of her that way before.
It was Halloween and our friends hosted a private hayride through backroads. This was to be followed by a party at an older friends house. Apparently, my friend (I will call him Greg) wanted to be more off-again with Shelley that day and he had given some thought to the matter. On the hayride, he proposed that he get her into bed and then we somehow switch places without her knowing.
Like you, I assumed that was impossible except in movies. However, he explained that we were the same build, same hair color, and were dressed very similar that night. Furthermore the house that we were going to after had a bedroom that was unusually dark with the the super-shades closed.
I agreed to give it a try assuming it wouldn’t work. We went to the house for the party, I went into the bedroom, removed my shirt, and hid in the closet. He brought her into the bedroom, they laid on the bed and started making out real heavy. At some point he said “Let me take off my shirt”, stood up, and I knew it was my cue like we rehearsed it and he got in the closet.
You would assume that a woman could tell a substitution in lovers but she could not. We made out for a good 20 minutes and I gently grunted and groaned if talking came into play. The good news is that I didn’t want to get too deep into this whole thing and as luck would have it, she was on her period that night so there was no actual sex and I would not have done that anyway. It was mainly kissing and light petting.
After a while, I decided that had gone on long enough and I just get up silently. She asked “What are you doing?” and Greg knew that was his cue and he stepped out of the closet, I stepped in and he replied to her.
She never found out the scoop that night at all. Greg and I probably would have never told her but other people thought that it was a little much not to share so they told her. She did not believe them. Would you?
I never really knew if she believed the story was real or if the story itself was the joke. In any case, we remained friends after that and I we never talked about it at all.