Inspired by Pilot141’s post in my “Scariest Forza Car” thread, I decided to make up a little challenge to any Dopers with F-4…
The “Gutless Wonder” race…
The rules are simple;
Class F cars only
Performance Index of no more than 102 points
Automatic transmission
Antilock brakes
all other assists OFF, no traction control, no stability control, no racing line, the only permitted assists are ABS and Automatic
Cockpit view (behind the steering wheel)
No Rewind
Track is Stage B of Fujimi Kaido (the really twisty uphill part)
Run the track in your choice of Gutless Wonder and post your best time
in my game, the available cars would be; (Car / Class / PI / HP / TQ)
Citroen C1 / F / 101 / 67 HP / 69 TQ
Ford Pinto / F /100 /85 HP / 98 TQ *
Peugeot 107 / F / 102 /68 HP / 70 TQ
Toyota Aygo / F / 100 / 68 HP / 69 TQ
VW Fox / F / 101 / 74 HP / 91 TQ
VW Scirocco S / F / 102 / 74 HP / 89 TQ *
- DLC cars not in base game
Here’s my times, no practice laps, just pick up n’ play
VW Scirocco; 4:20*
VW Fox; 4:27**
Toyota Aygo; 4:35***
Peugeot 107; 4:16****
Ford Pinto; 4:14*****
Citroen C1; 4:17******
- nothing memorable here, just mediocrity
**an absolute slug acceleration-wise, but very sharp and crisp handling
***absolutely NO acceleration worth mentioning, engine only seems to get power on the high end of the RPM band, this one needs to be revved hard and high to even be marginally useful, not to say fun, 0-60 time? yes, eventually, and to make matters worse, it has a horrible, floaty steering feel and suspension that feels like it’s made of marshmallows, truly a horrible car
****At first this felt as soggy and mushy as the accursed Aygo, but once I got used to the suspension and chassis “quirks” I was able to slide through corners (I would say "Power"slide, but you need to have power to do a powerslide), still a tad too floaty for my tastes, the VW Fox had much nicer driving dynamics
*****Frankly, I’m stunned, I didn’t expect this, so far, of all the cars driven in the Gutless Wonder challenge, the one I’ve not only got the best time in, AND had the most FUN in, what was arguably the “worst” car of the bunch!
I can’t deny that when compared against the other F-Class 100’ish PI index cars, the lowly Pinto can not only hold it’s own, but come out pretty darned good actually, and actually be FUN to drive to boot!
Since the Pinto was the only rear-wheel-drive car in the bunch, I was able to keep the anemic powerband in the sweet spot and kick the tail out in the corners, saving time and preserving forward momentum, and as any driving enthusiast knows, RWD is preferred for keeping the car balanced handling-wise, there’s a reason so many performance cars are either RWD or Mid-Engined-Rear-Drive (MRD)
Plus, the Pinto had the highest Torque numbers of the bunch, and Torque is what gets you off the line and pushes you back in your seat, all other things being equal, a car with a torquier motor will “feel” faster than one with less torque, even if the HP numbers are identical, the Torque of the Pinto’s motor was able to keep it pushing uphill even while gasping for breath without having to have the transmission “kick down” a gear
****** The Citroen was easily my favorite front-wheel-drive car in the Gutless Wonder Challenge, it had the crisp handling of the VW Fox, a usable mid-range grunt, reasonably stiff suspension, and it just felt sharp and precise, easily the most balanced car in the challenge, when compared against it’s fellow front-drive brethren.
For most of the Citroen race, I was playing leapfrog with the Pinto’s Ghost Car, I had a slight edge on the straightaways, due to the more modern, efficient powertrain, but what killed me was the brutal understeer in tight corners, in the Citroen, I had to brake hard when entering the corner, then accelerate near the apex of the turn, scrubbing off valuable forward momentum and speed, with the Pinto, I’d come off the throttle a bit when entering the turn, then give it a little goose to break the rear wheels free and oversteer through the corner
When it comes to performance driving, I’m just more comfortable with a rear-drive car, the handling and power delivery just seem more balanced…
…maybe that’s why I convert all my FWD cars in Forza 4 to RWD, if it’s an option, it’s the simplest and most effective way to balance out the handling
So, my fellow Forza drivers, go choose your favorite Gutless Wonder and attack the hills and twisties of Fujimi Kaido