I think the priest’s dilemma is that he genuinely is a timid person. When the outbreak happened, he probably panicked and locked himself inside the church, and let the people outside get killed by zombies. I actually believe that the priest is who he says he is.
The good news is that there aren’t any producers on Talking Dead, so we don’t have to discuss anything that really happened, but which we didn’t see.
Not sure what’s going on with kidnapped Beth and the car with the cross on it, but even though there is an obvious huge connection with the church and the priest, I don’t think the two are related. I don’t have anything to go off to say that. Just intuition.
The priest, if to be believed, says that he wasn’t getting out much, and had no use for the bus. So, maybe the car with the cross on it belonged to the church at one time, but was stolen?
Also, remember, Beth was kidnapped from a moratorium. Well, some place that embalmed and maybe cremated cadavers. The car could belong to the moratorium. I believe that whoever was in charge of that place is the culprit in Beth’s kidnapping. And, I think if there is any connection to the priest, it is that, since it’s a small town, the priest knows who that person is, but maybe not what they are up to.
But, man, that car with the cross on it certainly is always in a hurry.
Oo! Totally a way-out-there hypothesis, but maybe that mortician, who is adept in dealing with corpses, was one of the people the priest locked out. Knowing the priest is timid, he is assembling an army of zombies to wreck revenge upon the priest.
But, more importantly, let’s get to Gareth and Bob.
It was posited and suggested before that Bob is some bad-luck charm. When the group encountered him, he was alone, sad, and told a story about how he was previously with two other groups, but that he was the sole survivor of both groups.
Then, Gareth is talking as if they have a history together, and that it was a pleasant cosmic coincidence that they should meet again. I have a feeling that Bob is responsible for all the bad things that happened to Terminus the first time.