Ruby Keeler, Dick Powell, Joan Blondell–“Dames”
Try again. Hint: Think of the 4th cast member–it’s a biggee.
I’ve got a game ready whenever we need a new one.
!!! It’s Foolight Parade !!!
Ding ding ding. I assume you know who the 4th cast member is.
So far:
Cary Grant
Edward Everett Horton
from Bell Book and Candle - Jack Lemmon
from Libeled Lady - William Powell
from Footlight Parade - James Cagney
together we get Mister Roberts with Henry Fonda
:D:D:D this is fun!!!
Advise and Consent
?
Yes on all counts. Good job! 
Robot Arm, I am impressed. You can piece out the formula or let the others figure it out…
I’m working on it.
now I’m lost
I can put Cary Grant & Edward Everett Horton together in Arsenic and Old Lace
I can put Cary Grant with Katherine Hepburn (from Stage Door) together in Bringing Up Baby
But I can’t fit a third actor in from the remaining movies
and besides - it’s time for Veronica Mars - I’ll be back later
Neither movie is correct, though both combos are.
Grant, Hepburn, and Norton were in Holiday, but that wouldn’t be right, would it?
Actually, can we get a recap?
Are there any 1st stage actors left unsolved? What are the solved 2nd stage actors?
Assuming Holiday is right, we still need actors from…
The Ten Commandments
Sunset Blvd.
Touch of Evil
And I’m still working on it.
from the Ten Commandments, it’s either Yul Brenner or Anne Baxter
From Sunset Blvd - I’m thinking either Jack Webb or Buster Keaton
and from Touch of Evil, all I could come up with was Dennis Weaver, but that’s probably wrong
now if we change Edward Everett Horton to John Howard (both in Lost Horizon)
and add him to Cary Grant and Katherine Hpeburn, we get
The Philadelphia Story
but that’s probably wrong, too, huh?
and from there, leap to
[spoiler]Jimmy Stewart[/spolier]
CG & EEH were both in the 1933 production of Alice in Wonderland… but that’s not it, is it?
AHA!!!
Lost Horizon - EEH
Gunga Din - CG
Stage Door - KH
all three were in Holiday
also in the cast was i have no freakin clue who you have in mind