as for the final answer, i thought maybe you were aiming for The Da Vinci Code , then I realized that that movie would have to be a second rounder because of Jürgen Prochnow
Am I on the right track?
Last Action Hero with
Art Carney
Anthony Quinn
Joan Plowright
&
Ian McKellan
are you using made for TV movies? or theatrical releases only?
Dorothy Malone is also in Pushover.
AH!
Pushover:
Philip Carey
E.G. Marshall
Dorothy Malone
and
**Robert Stevenson **
Just a Gigolo:
Kim Novak
David Hemmings
Marlene Dietrich
and
David Bowie
ok - i’ll just slink over into this corner now…
**The Hunt For Red October
**Tim Curry
James Earl Jones
Sean Connery
with Alec Baldwin (or maybe Courtney B Vance)
Right on everything except Stevenson.
Pochacco , you’re correct as well.
rose , I didn’t quite get your spoiler, but I think you are on the right track.
BTW, theatrical releases only.
Remaing list:
Claire Bloom
Sean Connery
Tim Curry
Cedric Hardwicke
James Earl Jones
Agnes Moorehead
Laurence Olivier
Gregory Peck
James Stewart
2nd round actors correct so far: Stanton, Widmark, McKellan, Prochnow
Right on everything except Stevenson.
Pochacco , you’re correct as well.
rose , I didn’t quite get your spoiler, but I think you are on the right track.
BTW, theatrical releases only.
Remaing list:
Claire Bloom
Sean Connery
Tim Curry
Cedric Hardwicke
James Earl Jones
Agnes Moorehead
Laurence Olivier
Gregory Peck
James Stewart
2nd round actors correct so far: Stanton, Widmark, McKellan, Prochnow, Bowie
Not Baldwin or Vance, otherwise right.
Pushover 4th is Fred MacMurray?
Scott Glenn or Sam Neill ?
Which one? 
Richard III
Claire Bloom
Cedric Hardwicke
Laurence Olivier
with (Sir) Ralph Richardson
<sigh> Sam Neill
btw - did you see this?
At least you got your fourth person right! I may be guessing awhile (unless someone else takes over). 
And Bowie?
Arg! There are so many - are there any futher clues on how to pick #4 other than someone else in the same movie?
:smack: I skipped this post thinking it was a duplicate.
ok - I have the first round two movie
Twin Peaks: Fire Walk with Me
Harry Dean Stanton
Jürgen Prochnow
David Bowie
with Heather Graham?
No, I didn’t–both correct!
Only 6 left on the list and 2 2nd rounders:
Bloom, Moorehead, Olivier, Peck, Hardwicke, Stewart
2nd rounders correct: Sam Neill, Ian McKellan, Richard Widmark, Harry Dean Stanton, Fred MacMurray, Jurgen Prochnow, David Bowie
Not Heather Graham, otherwise right.