Disclaimer One: I am a libertarian in my political views. I am against both subjects. I have always felt that government interference into economic and social issues only causes more strife.
Disclaimer Two: This thread is partly inspired by Shodan’s brilliant rebuttals in another thread from about a week ago, which I cannot find right now, in which the subject was about Affirmative Action. It is also partly inspired by the fact that I have heard the topic of Slave Reparations come up a handful of times in the past month. Maybe the planets are aligned or something.
Slave Reparations and Social Security have both been on my mind lately. Maybe I have thought about them too much, and have passed over into that metaphysical unreality where everything, and nothing, makes sense, but here goes.
I feel that when the government dabbles in economic and social issues, it only leads to inflated supply or demand, and more social segregation. As the old sayings go, “The path to Hell is paved with good intentions,” and, “No good deed goes unpunished.” While a better outcome was envisioned for both subjects, reality has a nasty way of making the opposite come true.
I guess you could say, the mixing and remixing of the previous paragraph in my head led to a sort of epiphany. Maybe we should plan for the opposite to happen, and actually hope that it does.
Social Security. It was never supposed to bankroll the retirement plans of America’s elderly. Oh, well. So much for that.
But. I have the yearnings of an entrepreneur. I have several different business opportunities that I am pursuing all at the same time. A few business plans have failed in the past. This had put my financially behind, but I paid my dues, picked up the pieces, and moved on.
Here’s my thought. If just one of my business ideas takes off, through some hard work, I could become very wealthy. I would have to hire others, and pay them well. I would supply them with benefits and health plans and retirement plans. They could afford a better lifestyle, which means we all would be paying more taxes. Win/win situation. It’s the American Dream.
However, if none of my ideas ever take off, and I end up flopping from bankruptcy to bankruptcy through my middle age, I won’t have enough to retire. “So, Chicago Faucet, don’t retire. Work until you die. Boo Hoo.” one might say.
That’s all fine and dandy, except that the expectation is that I should be able to retire at a certain age. Should I be punished for pursuing a better wealth, which in turn would make others wealthy as well, and generate more tax revenue, except that it didn’t work out that way?
So here’s the spin. We should have a national retirement plan with all the bells and whistles included. After age 65, we should have a monthly check sent to us from the govnerment, and full medical benefits. That way, people like myself, who are repeatedly trying to create the next Big Company aren’t held back by the fear of not having enough to retire. If we are guaranteed a nice retirement, this plan would encourage people to take a few more risks in their younger years, with the expectation that a certain percentage will actually pay of a hundred fold, making life better for everyone.
Slave Reparations. Touchy subject. We gave similar reparations to Native Americans, but not to the Chinese or Hispanics.
Here’s the spin. We do the old, “40 Acres And A Mule,” proposition that was floated after the Civil War. We give each African American who can trace their lineage directly to a slave that was emancipated, today’s financial equivalent of 40 acres and a mule. This money comes from equal amounts the companies that profitted from slavery and our government.
Suddenly you have America’s second largest minority walking around with pockets full of cash.
You want to talk about financial and economic recovery! Wooo!
Consumerism would hit an all time high. The stock market would boom - making everyone rich - that is, after the initial crash when the legislation was passed. House sales would skyrocket. Car sales would skyrocket. Expendable and durable goods would skyrocket. Companies would be hiring all over the place. Everyone would have a job. Talk about a retail dream!
Any comments?