A plea for political civility (yes, even in the pit)

As Dopers our mission statement, if you will, is to fight ignorance.
As such, I feel it is essential that we refine our usage of language to give it greater resonance with reality.

Statements such as “The Republicans blah blah blah…” “The Liberals blah blah blah…” serve no real purpose. I have news for y’all, The Republicans do not exist. They just don’t. Neither do The Democrats.

There are people, messy, chaotic, organic people who happen to belong to political camps. But there is certainly no uniformity in their beliefs, attitudes, actions, etc… Any attempt to make groups fungible does a fundamental disservice to the cause of fighting ignorance.

Categories are linguistic fictions.
The degree to which we act as if they are real is the degree to which we divorce ourselves from reality.

It is a sloppy and lazy tactic to describe all of your ‘opposition’ with one-word-generalizations. Instead of discussing what certain people who happen to be republicans think/feel/do, it’s easier to say “The Republicans are…”
But it’s also totally false to facts, and ends up painting your fellow Dopers with a brush that they may or may not deserve.

This goes double for oh-so-cute phrases like “The Repugs.”

Can we just drop this shit?
Even in terms of our politicians there is debate and disagreement.
There is individuality, growth, change, uniqueness.

Let’s play straight here.
Please.

P.S. As a caveat, I am sure that I’m guilty of this to a certain degree. And yes, I would appreciate being called on it when and if I screw up.
P.P.S. No, I don’t have any cites, but any casual browsing of recent threads should turn up enough example to kill a horse.

Finn good luck with this, but don’t hold your breath.

Hear hear, FinnAgain! That kind of crap just drives me crazy.

Nice idea, but it stands no chance in hell.

The conservatives are all the same-- they’ll never agree to this. Same thing for the liberals.

Yeah, let me know how this thread works out for you.

You have my full support! Lets do it.

A suggestion: let’s turn this thread into a cesspool.

No, not right now: do you go out back to your cesspool and splash around in it? If you do, you’re not invited to my house.

When you encounter stanky crap, however, you send it to the cesspool. And that’s what I think we should do: when someone makes these types of obnoxious generalizations, instead of responding to them in the thread where they occur, point them here.

I think Lib pioneered this posting strategy with Desmo awhile ago; I like the idea.

Daniel

Loach, Exgineer: S’okay, I’ve got a place in my heart for lost causes.

Liberal: ~bows humbly~ Thank you kindly.

John Mace: :smiley:

Lord Ashtar: You want emails or smoke signals? :wink:

Khadaji: Alright! You, me, and Lib makes an army of three. Soon we will be unstoppable! (mwahahaha)

Seriously though folks, the responsibility, and the power, is in our hands. We help set the tone of the boards, we help define what is acceptable behavior and what isn’t.
If, as Dopers, we don’t put up with this sort of stuff when we see it happening, I honestly believe that it will become de rigeur.

On preview Left Hand of Dorkness: As the OP, I wouldn’t be opposed to that idea. Not totally sold on it however, I still think it would be useful if, in threads where it happens, people are, gently yet firmly, shown the error of their rhetoric.

Perhaps. My experience is that people respond to such gentle corrections with shrill denials that they’ve done anything wrong, often extending to the multiples of pages, and often leading to a fatal threadjack. A link to this thread might keep this as the place for the shrill denials, keeping the original thread (relatively) clean.

Daniel

Finn: fuck you!

(Oh, and I totally agree with your OP. Even though it won’t work.)

Asshole!

FinnAgain
I appreciate the nobility of your starting this thread in the attempt to bring civility and comportment to this message board particularly with political topics.
I agree with you 100 per cent except you are forgetting one important fact. When it comes to uncivil behavior and inappropriate language - the “Repugs” started it !!!

Did not
Did too
Did not
Did too
Did not
Did too

I appreciate the opportunity to discuss this topic in a mature and sophisticated manner.


I’m George “Dubya” Bush and I disprove this massage.

To important an idea–it needs it’s own thread.

When ready, simply start a thread called “The Cesspool of Peurile Partisanship” or some such and, when ready, begin politely referring people.

Giraffe : Cool cool, I’m not quite ready to give up on it just yet. (motherfucker)
wolf_meister: Noble? Awwwww shucks…

I think we should vote on this.

Honestly?
Or have I been wooshed?

Then maybe you should stop doing it. Just a wild thought, mind you.

see also irony

Applause for a most worthy endeavor. The months leading up to the election really became tiresome. Hopefully all of the goat-felching, otter-sniffing, syphlitic pus bags who like to call others names will be nicely cooperative. :wink:

danceswithcats: Thank you.
I wonder if it wouldn’t be possible to procure a load of Dr. Weird’s phone spiders and modify them for internet use…