[QUOTE=Nava]
Ooook… so, uh, what color will the Hispanics be? Before I open my mouth or show my passport, US Customs agents in Miami take me for cuban; in Texas, for American. Reentering the US from Mexico in Austin, I had to refuse to move along until the Customs agent stamped my passport, he didn’t want to on grounds of me being American (that would have been nice, double nationality, but I’m afraid nationality is not based on how you look to a Customs agent). I know Hispanic black, Hispanic coffee-with-milk, Hispanic caramel (some black blood someplace, but go and look for it), Hispanic red, Hispanic polka-dot (one parent “indian”, one white), Hispanic yellow (both parents Vietnamese; both parents Chinese)… gee, guess we should come up with a nick for “yellow with white”, how about “Hispanic vanilla”? Vanilla is good, second most popular ice-cream flavor in Spain! (Lemon is the first)
Oh, and let’s not forget Hispanic gypsies, who range from caramel to white and back.
[/QUOTE]
Hmm…that give me an idea for next year.
Hispanics could be the x-factor. During critical parts of Survivor, the contestants can reveal their “double allegiance”.
And all you folks crying “raciscm!” right now are just doing CBS’s promotion work for them! You are creating the buzz that will lead more viewers to the trough.
[/QUOTE]
[QUOTE=don’t ask]
The show will never begin. The producers will attempt to divide the players in to “racial” groups but after months of trying to split them up they will discover that race “is just a social construct” and we can’t with any accuracy ascribe a “race” to any individual because there are greater differences between members of the same “racial” group than there are between people from different racial groups etc
[/QUOTE]
Now that would be funny.
I await this edition of Survivor with my usual level of excitement and anticipation, i.e., exactly zero.
[QUOTE=you with the face]
Aaaargh! monstro didn’t write the above. T’was me.
[/QUOTE]
You’ve stated this exact thing before (different thread), I believe w.r.t. monstro. I’m confused. Are you saying you agree with monstro or you really are monstro?
[QUOTE=don’t ask]
The show will never begin. The producers will attempt to divide the players in to “racial” groups but after months of trying to split them up they will discover that race “is just a social construct” and we can’t with any accuracy ascribe a “race” to any individual because there are greater differences between members of the same “racial” group than there are between people from different racial groups etc
[/QUOTE]
Nonsense. They’ll probably have 10,000 applicants, they’ll end of selecting by skin tom=ne and what their last name sounds like, and they’ll CALL it race. Just like most people.
[QUOTE=RaftPeople]
You’ve stated this exact thing before (different thread), I believe w.r.t. monstro. I’m confused. Are you saying you agree with monstro or you really are monstro?
[/QUOTE]
monstro and you with the face are sisters (twins, I believe). I think that ywtf was indicating that they were posting from the same computer and that she forgot to switch the logins.
If they want to gererate a REAL buzz, the producers should have tribes of Christians, Jews, Muslims and Hindus. The competitions would be: cross burning, money lending, car bombing, and eating burgers.
[QUOTE=RaftPeople]
You’ve stated this exact thing before (different thread), I believe w.r.t. monstro. I’m confused. Are you saying you agree with monstro or you really are monstro?
[/QUOTE]
I just came back from Miami, visiting my twin sister. She’d logged on to the Dope thru my laptop and I realized that she forgot to log off when I made that post.
[QUOTE=you with the face]
I just came back from Miami, visiting my twin sister. She’d logged on to the Dope thru my laptop and I realized that she forgot to log off when I made that post.
[QUOTE=don’t ask]
The show will never begin. The producers will attempt to divide the players in to “racial” groups but after months of trying to split them up they will discover that race “is just a social construct” and we can’t with any accuracy ascribe a “race” to any individual because there are greater differences between members of the same “racial” group than there are between people from different racial groups etc
[/QUOTE]
[QUOTE=you with the face]
I just came back from Miami, visiting my twin sister. She’d logged on to the Dope thru my laptop and I realized that she forgot to log off when I made that post.
These things happen.
[/QUOTE]
Identical? and did you both arrive at SDMB independently? That would be kind of cool.
A friend at work told me today that his cousin, Sekou Bunch, was one of the players on this series of Survivor. I’m debating whether or not I should pump him for inside information.
How about Survivor : children. We could watch Lord of the Flies unfold in front of our very eyes!
[/QUOTE]
Considering that, back in the day, it was very common for networks to produce kids’ versions of popular game shows (e.g. Storybook Squares), this may not be too far-fetched.
As far as the OP goes, I personally have no problem with this season’s premise at all. As has been mentioned already, the original divisions will probably only last 1 or 2 episodes, like the older/younger men/women in Panama. By the 2nd episode, the tribes were re-shuffled. It’s a ratings ploy, pure and simple, and the bigger stink people raise about it, the higher the ratings will be.
And, for the uninitiated who think CBS will change their minds, the show is already completed.
[QUOTE=you with the face]
Fraternal. monstro discovered the place first and then told me about it.
[/QUOTE]
I really did not need to know this. My intelligent-twin-sister fantasy is working overtime.
These cries of segregation ring false when said segregation is entirely voluntary. It’s difficult to oppress people who signed up for it, you know?
As for the idea that the producers will give up when they realize that race is an artificial construct, come on. Most people self-identify with a race (or multiple races). That gives you a pretty good starting point, don’t you think?
oh, and you with the face? This seems like a good place to mention just how much I’ve always loved your user name. It never fails to bring me a smile.