Okay, Mark Thompson is back on the air in the SoCal radio market. THAT Mark Thompson. I’ve been listening to the program in a somewhat desultory and haphazard way, just to see if he’s going to be as easy to get concert tickets and other goodies as he used to be when he was partnered up with his (imho) less a-hole-ish buddy.
I haven’t drawn any conclusions yet on that question, but his current shenanigans are largely featuring his stated goal of becoming best friends with Kevin Spacey. To that end, last week, he played a short clip of dialog (or monologue, I guess) from The Usual Suspects, of which one of the salient lines was:
(Okay, it’s a rephrasing of an “observation” by Baudelaire; I first heard this specious bit of “philosophy” nearly twenty years ago, on a Paul Harvey broadcast).
The point is, it irritated me considerably, since, even before I cast off my belief in Abrahamic monotheism, I stopped believing in the existence of such an entity as “the Devil.” From the first time I heard it, I looked upon the statement as inane, facile, and lazy.
So, those are some adjectives that describe the statement’s failings. What I’m wondering, as one may surmise from the thread title, is: does this statement fall under some kind of classification, such as a fallacy of some sort?
It seems to bear at least some of the hallmarks of “begging the question,” but that doesn’t strike me as particularly satisfying. Is there a more accurate descriptor of such a “gotcha,” and are there any examples of other sayings that fit the classification?