Actors who are seen as often "playing themselves"

Certain actors are often considered to be “playing themselves” in many of their roles. It seems to be somewhat insulting because it implies a limit in range and that they can only play roles that fit their perceived selves. What actors out there are often viewed as “playing themselves” and can you think of a role or two from that actor that went against that trend?

Jack Nicholson comes to mind, especially regarding his later career (from the mid-80’s and beyond). A lot of his characters are pretty similar and fitting the template of Jack’s perceived persona. I think the big exception was Col. Jessup from A Few Good Men. It was a role unlike any other for Nicholson in that era and, ultimately, was one of his best acting performances.

Samuel L. Jackson also plays very similar characters. His exception may be his role in the Star Wars films. Michael J. Fox is another one. Earlier in his career before his unfortunate illness, he played quite a few similar characters. Even in an intense, dramatic war film like Casualties of War, his character looked like Alex P. Keaton dropped in the middle of the Vietnam conflict.

John Wayne was the ultimate in playing himself. Did he ever have a stellar acting performance in a role that countered his image?

What do you think? Is this something that you see with younger actors today?..women?..etc???
:

Ricky Gervaise.

Robert De Niro has to be right up there.

Tom Cruise. But whether he plays the same character all the time because that’s what he’s like, or because it’s the only character he knows how to play, I don’t know.

Nic Cage. Vince Vaughn. Owen Wilson. Ryan Reynolds. Robin Williams.

Don’t misunderstand me Ryan Reynolds and Robin Williams are very good at it, but you usually know what kind of performance you’re going to get.

As @Princhester said, I guess I’m not too confident about naming people who always play the same character, because I’m not sure it that’s them in real life, or if it’s the only role they know how to play.

But I always thought Clint Eastwood was the archetype. When he got out of the car in Gran Torino he might as well have been wearing a poncho and spurs.

For younger actors, the first that comes to mind for me is Michael Cera, who seems to pretty much always be George Michael Bluth.

Al Pacino has, like Nicholson, risen or fallen to this level.

I must respectfully disagree. While Robin Williams often played the wild and crazy comic, he also took on roles that were darker or more subdued. (I’m thinking of the one where he played a photo developer who stalks a family). Admittedly, both types - zany and depressive - reflected parts of his true persona, but he definitely had a range in the roles he played.

With Robin Williams, who I love, there was a lot of subtlety, but if you were going to see him in a comedy, it usually wasn’t a restrained Robin Williams you were going to get.

I’m not saying that to slight him. He’s one of my favorite actor/comedians. But even some of his more serious turns had the manic side creeping in (I’m looking at you, Good Morning, Vietnam)

Woody Allen.

John Malkovich

Imgur

Brad Pitt. Leonardo DiCaprio. I like both but you always know what you’re gonna get.

Madonna.

But she is not principally known as an actor, and so was generally cast in a movie specifically to play the persona she presented when she performed on stage as a singer-- whether that was the real her, or just a character she had worked up to front her singing act, I have no idea, though. She seemed to keep it up in interviews, but that means nothing.

FWIW, “playing yourself” is not as easy as it sounds. Yes, developing a character a la Kathy Bates, Meryl Streep, Lucy Lawless (yes-- see something besides Xena– she’s very talented), John Hurt, Ian Holm, or other actors who are thought of very highly is challenging, that doesn’t mean that delivering lines naturally in front of a camera is something anyone can do.

Just witness how very badly some non-actors have done in cameos. Buzz Aldrin played himself in an episode of 30 Rock, and he was just awful. He was so wooden, well, the jokes are too easy, so I won’t make one. I’m surprised they left his scenes in the episode.

He’s not the only one. If you’ve seen Aldrin, or someone like him, it really makes you appreciate how well so many of the non-actors who pop up in The Big Bang Theory– Neil De Grasse Tyson, Mike Massimino, and others, do in their cameos. TBBT casting people, or maybe episode directors-- someone-- really knew how to get good cameo appearances.

Anyway, while Madonna may not be great at developing characters, she is dynamite when playing Madonna, and deserves credit for that.

12 Monkeys Brad Pitt, vs. Snatch Brad Pitt, vs. Inglorious Basterds Brad Pitt, vs. Interview With a Vampire Brad Pitt never felt like the same characters to me.

Agreed - Snatch first made me appreciate that Pitt is not just a pretty face, he’s a very talented actor.

Mark Wahlberg

De Niro has never really acted, he was just allowed to be a thug on camera. His “comedies” are abysmal.

Most action stars—Arnold Schwarzenegger, Sylvester Stallone, Jean Claude van Damme, Steven Seagal, Chuck Norris…

Some of them have more charisma and are better at it than others. Of then ones I mentioned Seagal stands out as being more limited than the others