Admiral Nelson's Corpse Q

There’s a charming song called “A Drop of Nelson’s Blood.” Supposedly, after Lord Admiral Nelson was killed at Trafalgar, they put his dead body in the last remaining barrel of rum to preserve it. On the arduous journey back to England, some of the sailors took to putting long straws through a tiny hole in the top, to get a mouthful of the only rum left on the ship. By the time they pulled into port, the corpse was bone dry. “A drop of Nelson’s blood wouldn’t do us any harm…”

I have my doubts about the story, of course. For one thing, Trafalgar isn’t all that far from Portsmouth, 2-3 days tops unless they’re fighting headwinds, so this ghoulish drinking frenzy would have had to happen over a matter of hours, not weeks. I couldn’t find online how long it actually took them to bring Nelson’s body home. Do any history buffs have this info handy? Could any part of this story plausibly have happened?

It’s a fairly length story, but the National Archives lays out the dates. He went into the brandy cask on October 22nd and reached Gibraltar in it on the 28th. The body, having undergone various different encasements, then doesn’t reach London until December.

I’ve heard this story before, and I agree that it doesn’t seem plausible. The details of how the body was preserved are recounted here, and long story short there was a lot of booze involved, but mostly it was brandy.

Ah, okay! I’m comparing the sailing time to a transatlantic journey (6-8 weeks under good conditions) and this journey had long storms, a hurricane, and heavily damaged ships towing other heavily damaged ships, in addition to the French navy still trying to recover their captured ships en route.

A similar tale is told of one of my ancestors. I actually e-mailed the great folklore scholar Jan Brunvand about it many years ago, and he pointed me to his analysis of the legend in The Choking Doberman (1984). He calls the legend “The Corpse in the Cask.” The story is told about many different people at many different times and places. In addition to Nelson, Brunvand notes the case of General Edward Pakenham, the British officer who was killed at the Battle of New Orleans (1815). According to this version of the story, the ship carrying his body was diverted to South Carolina, where the locals sampled the wine he was stored in.

Is any version of the story true? Nobody knows for sure, but the fact that it’s told with about so many people with minor variations suggests to me that it’s a legend with no basis except in the imagination of the original teller.

More information here: Tapping the Admiral: Nelson, Trafalgar & the Corpse in the Cask – #FolkloreThursday

From Doctor Beattie’s statement:-

Dr. Stephen Maturin, a naturalist as well as a surgeon in Patrick O’Brian’s terrific series of Napoleonic naval adventure novels, several times notes the usefulness of spirit of wine for preserving specimens, including in The Fortune of War, which I just finished.

When I first read the thread title, my first thought was “But Richard Basehart died a long time ago. What are they doing with his corpse?”