Albums where (almost) every song is known

Cafe Society
61

Boston’s first may take it, since I know all the songs but never owned the album.
The Police, Syncronicity is another one for me:
Side one

  1. “Synchronicity I”
  2. “Walking in Your Footsteps”
  3. “O My God”
  4. “Mother” (Andy Summers)
  5. “Miss Gradenko” (Stewart Copeland)
  6. “Synchronicity II”
    Side two
  7. “Every Breath You Take”
  8. “King of Pain”
  9. “Wrapped Around Your Finger”
  10. “Tea in the Sahara”
  11. “Murder by Numbers” (Summers, Sting)
62

Especially since they all sound pretty much the same. I guy across the hall in my freshman dorm played that album constantly, to the point where I never want to hear any of it again.

63

Alan Parson’s I* Robot* is a pretty good match for the OP, for prog rock fans at least, but it did cross over into the mainstream as well.

  1. I Robot
  2. I Wouldn’t Want To Be Like You
  3. Some Other Time
  4. Breakdown
  5. Don’t Let It Show
  6. The Voice
  7. Nucleus
  8. Day After Day (The Show Must Go On)
  9. Total Eclipse
  10. Genesis Ch. 1 V. 32