There are a few artists who have written a lot of great songs, but the songs that get the most airplay are inferior works, far less powerful than most of their work. (Clearly this is a matter of opinion, but I bet it will be fairly easy to come to a consensus in many cases.)
I’ll start by nominating the song that inspired the topic: “Have you ever seen the rain?” by Creedence Clearwater Revival. The lugubrious exercise in kvetching in a low, moany, whiny voice is orders of magnitude worse than anything else CCR has done, especially worse than their other hits. It can’t compare to the driving urgency of “Born on A Bayou” or the hypnotic thrill of Suzy Q or the infectious joy of “Looking Out My Back Door.”
The song sucks, it blows, and it’s far and away the one most frequently played on the radio. I do not understand!
The floor is open for counterarguments and other nominees.
I don’t hear that one all that often on the local classic rock station. If we get CCR , it is usually Fortunate Son, Born on the Bayou, or Bad Moon Rising.
Do you have a cite that it plays more often? I don’t recall hearing it in years. Maybe you have a local radio programmer who has a fetish over the song.
I would guess that Fortunate Son gets more play, though I don’t have any evidence.
I think Tom Petty is a great performer who has put out a variety of songs. He has a lot that havce gotten airplay, but the worst one he had that was popular was Freefallin’
It’s a three cord, three cord song. A three cord, three cord song
I’m a huge fan of Todd Rundgren. Between his solo works and the bands he has lead, he’d written hundreds of songs and several dozen albums, ranging from pop and rock, to blues, Philly soul, prog rock, techno, show tunes and even bossa-nova and rap.
So why, in the name of all that is holy, is the stupidest thing he ever penned his most popular? Why is it played on commercials and sporting events?
Van Morrison - Brown Eyed Girl
J. Geils - Freeze Frame
Grateful Dead - Truckin’ / Casey Jones
The Band - The Weight/Up On Cripple Creek
Canned Heat - Goin’ Up The Country
Yeah, but those weren’t weak songs. Plus, I hear Purple Haze. And, some of the really guitar-centered stuff is not all that approachable by a general audience.
I’m going to have to nominate Lionel Ritchie. I think he wrote most of the songs for the Commodores, and some of that stuff was just fantastic. His solo stuff, which gets much, much more airplay is not just weak compared to his other stuff, it’s just awful in general.
How about Stevie Wonder? Some of the funkiest songs ever written were by him, but you hear “I Just Called to Say” or “Ebony and Ivory” or “Sunshine of My Eye”. Compare that to “Maybe your Baby” or “Higher Ground”
ETA: Have to agree with Mixolydian about Yes as well.