Maybe one could argue that the passer rating is not an accurate reflection of John Q. Quarterback, becuase maybe he throws the 8 yard pass so well he doesn’t even try for longer passes, something like that. But Vince Young this year is horrible in every possible individual category- TD’s, INT’s, yards per completion, yards per attempt, yards per game, etc. I think Eli Manning is taking much more shit (being in NY helps) for the same 6-2 record with much better stats than VY.
With the different systems different teams play, I don’t know what a good across-the-board system would look like.
Manning hasn’t taken any shit since about week 2. Although I may just be listening to less sports radio.
I’ll trade you Alex Smith for Vince Young…