My god. Another week of having to listen to that horrid girl sing…I thought for sure she was gone, I actually was CHEERING when she was announced as bottom three.
Ok, NEXT week she’s gone. She HAS to be.
Oh YES she is!!!
But her singing does suck :D.
I can live with this week’s result.
I haven’t liked Kimberley Caldwell from the word “go,” so now she’s gone. Good!
Maybe next week the planets will align themselves properly and Carmen will join Kimberley in Nobody-Land.
Then I’ll be happy.
Kim C deserved to go more than Carmen tonight only because of her hair. What was that???
I just…don’t get this. To me, Carmen is NOT HOT by any stretch of the imagination. Certainly not hotter than Kimberly C (even with her strange eyebrows). She has this weird buggy-eyed pug dog thing going on. Lovely figure, absolutely, but her face is freaky weird. And she has bad skin.
I agree with ISiddiqui, I think Carmen is absolutely h-o-t, hot!
And so it pains me to say that she should not be allowed to make it past next week, because she sings like Jim Carey as The Cable Guy.
Happy
I can live wih it this week better than last week. At least Carmen was in the bottom two, and Kim C was someone else who needed to go, just not before Carmen.
I t makes me a little uneasy that Josh has not been in the bottom three yet. He’s too mediocre to not have ever been there. I hope we don’t end up with a winner by virtue of patriotism rather than talent. I’m guessing Josh will be in the final three with Ruben and Clay, and may even get to the final two. I can appreciate the patriotic sentiment but Josh is not the most talented person in this contest and it would be unfair to the others if he was to win this thing because he wears a uniform.
As to Carmen’s hotness quotient, I find her pretty but not sexy. She’s a a little to cutesy for my taste, and I think she’s kind of a ham with all the innocent, wide-eyed facial expressions. Now, Julie was hot. Too bad she couldn’t sing.
I hate reading this. It AIN’T patriotism! It’s LOOKS! He’s the male Carmen (with more talent).
An ugly Marine would have been booted off by now.
Looks?! Do you mean there are actually women/gay men out there who consider Josh attractive? I would prefer Simon to Josh!
Carmen staying in the contest is utter bullshit. If she wins, or comes close to winning, I’m so going to disown the American public. What the fuck is wrong with us? Why? Why do you continue to subject our ears to this pain!?!?!
Carmen is pretty in a boring kind of way, I suppose. But good lord, the outfit she was wearing last night should disqualify her from the human race. How could anyone possibly see that outfit and think “Oh, that’s the perfect thing to wear on national television!”
I can’t believe that Goat Girl did not get the boot! That Hefty bag of a dress should have been enough to get rid of her. Mr. Cynical believes that she’s still hanging in there because she’s got the entire Morman population voting for her. Cripes, can’t someone just take her as a second or third wife and get her off this show?
What is with Carmen and Clay? I may have missed a thread on this, but what the hell was going on with those two last week?
I thought Carmen was going to lose her virginity on national television. (well, it IS FOX) Man, it was creepy.
Every girl in my school (Emory Law) that watches the show thinks that Josh is VERY hot.
Diogenes:
“I can live wih it this week better than last week. At least Carmen was in the bottom two, and Kim C was someone else who needed to go, just not before Carmen.”
My thoughts exactly.
I’m concerned about next week though. People say that Carmen will be eliminated next week, but I don’t know anymore. 
I share in the general WTFtitude. And allow me to join in and say that I think Josh is about as far from appealing as it could possibly ever get. For every strange/unpleasant expression that Clay can be accused of making, Josh has three. The weirdest mouth in the world. I think of him as Lumpy.
I’m not going to write that “Carmen has to go next week,” because I’ve done that for the past two weeks, and well…
I have a theory on her outfit though. Right before the show started, Carmen found herself stuck in Simon’s dressing room (for obvious reasons) and just threw on the first two things she could find: one of Simon’s t-shirts, and the curtains.
lol! 
I missed it this week. Is this the outfit you’re talking about?
You forgot to say that her mom dresses her funny.
Anyway, I just find this whole “but she’s hot” argument ridiculous. Let her go on that stupid “Are You Hot” show and stop subjecting us to her horrid singing.
My teenage daughter thinks Josh is hot. She oughta know.
Carmen is kinda cute, but she is not hot. Clay seems to think otherwise, though - are those gay vibes making her feel safe with him? Never mind; I don’t really want to know.
I can certainly go along with Kim C. going before her - I think most callers are voting on the entirety of what they’ve heard, not only on the current week’s single song. Carmen’s best has been better than Kim’s, and she could get some of it back. Kim was always the same hoarse, off-pitch Janis-Joplin-wannabe-but-can’t-be every sinle time.
Carmen should be next, though, and may be, but the others can stick around - she’s the last of the usually-annoying contestants.
What am I missing here about Carmen and Simon?
Miss Creant, Carmen was Simon’s wildcard pick. For a while (though not in recent weeks) Simon just couldn’t bring himself to say anything remotely negative about Carmen, regardless of how bad her bleating was. There has been some mild speculation that Carmen has been able to stay on the show because Simon wanted it that way (although there’s nothing I’ve seen that would substantiate that).
Slacker, that is indeed the outfit of which I speak. On the second viewing, I think it could also reasonably be called a “Little Mermaid costume gone wrong.”