So…that happened. It seemingly continued the trend of NBC trying to make all ANW events look exactly the same. (I’ve occasionally expressed worry that NvN was going to get thrown into the same homogenization vat, but now the truth looks like NBC hasn’t figured out a way to do it and that’s why it’s on ice.) It didn’t help that Eyes was in Dick Vitale Mode the entire freaking evening, blaring up even the most mundane moves into buzzer-beater status. Sheesh, it’s as if he was making up for the fans not being able to scream directly into the camera.
Remember that 1992 match between Jimmy Connors and Martina Navratilova (of which this is pretty much the only record that still exists?) How it was supposed to be this amazing battle of the sexes duel between two living legends, and Connors…who had two not-insignificant handicaps and was battling nerves, I might add…won pretty easily? And once this oh-so-epic clash was over, everyone went “Huh, guess biological differences really do make a difference in sports, who knew?” and roughly ten minutes later everyone forgot it ever happened? Same deal here, a big-sounding event with a big marquee and big names that simply did not live up to the hype and will most likely be just another chunk of flotsam in the vast murky ocean of reality TV, much like Strong. Dangit, that one deserved at least a second season.
Okay, you know the drill…
0:00 A whole lot of stating, restating, and re-restating what this event is. You know what it means when they do this? That they don’t have any actual accomplishments to hype up. Extremely bad sign. (And inexcusable, as NBC damn well knew that virtually none of these ladies did anything other than maybe hit a quallies buzzer, which is so dime-a-dozen at this point that trumpeting it seems downright patronizing.)
0:01 It’s hertory, Bodge! HERTORY!
0:02 Aw, crap. All twelve contestants compete on a quallies course, which, following usual procedure, is the same one from the most recent season), of which six…six…make it to the second round. That takes place on a 10-obstacle course, with the top four making it to the Power Tower. Uggggghhhh… Look…guys…I’m hardly impressed by most of these women, but jeez Louise, if you’re going to take the trouble to bring them all the way here for a special event, freaking get some use out of them! It continues to baffle me how one reality show after another takes weeks or even months to assemble its pool of contestants, and the instant the contest begins, it drops a damn cluster bomb on them. Why is the order of the day always eliminate, eliminate, eliminate? Wouldn’t some kind of scoring system work just fine? You know, like USA vs. The World has? Why can’t NBC ever standardize their good ideas?? Goddammit.
0:03 We kick things off with the rookie, Ashley McConville. Profile…
OKAY, TIME OUT - Really?? Freaking really?? Why is it that nowadays NBC only ever, ever, ever shows Kacy Catanzaro’s QUALLIES run??? Hey, I remember there being a siffies that year, and I remember Catanzaro completing the siffies course (Yo, check it out!), which was an enormously greater achievement by any metric! What is it with this freakish obsession with the easiest stage of the contest??? What is wrong with you people???
…which shows her completing a quallies course. Joy.
All right, since she’s the first runner, that means that she won’t be an embarrassment but ultimately not be a factor. Aaaaaaaand…nailed it, out on Sideways. Thanks for playing, drive home safely, enjoy the veal. Wait…is it enjoy the veal, then drive home safely? Yeah, that sounds better.
0:07 Sandy Zimmerman, the 44-year-old supermom. Profile is exactly the same as I remember it from past appearances. So is the run, for that matter, as it takes forever but somehow finds a buzzer. Consistency!
0:14 Hey, did you also know that Michelle Warnky Buurma is 11-1 all time in team events? It’s true! Too bad NBC has to pretend that team events never existed for what I’m assuming are reasons, thereby killing at least 80% of this field’s real accomplishments! (I can’t wait to see what they have for Clubhouse! ) She’s thinking of moving from active competition, which is an excellent idea as her big splash on Beehive proves that she just doesn’t have the muscle for this anymore. Age spares no one.
0:17 Tweb Tweb Tweb Tweb Tweb Tweb Tweb Tweb Tweb Tweb Tweb Tweb Tweb Tweb Tweb Tweb! Not so much fun NOW, is it?
0:25 Waiweewuwwawei. Because it’s not fair to the big names for the bottom-feeding trash to get the same coverage as them.
0:27 Usual awkward flailing profile for Meagan Martin, and then… Man, that looked rock-solid. And this after doing pretty badly on this course not too long ago.
0:36 Waiweewuwwawei #2, because that’s just the world we live in now. Then Alyssa Beird, who suffers a bad break on Sideways. Hopefully this is the only time this incredibly fluky, chancy part of the obstacle will be a factor.
0:41 Jessie Graff. Hits the buzzer. Celebrates a bit too much. Doesn’t look all that Wondrous. Take whatever joy you can.
0:49 And a goddam third waiweewuwwawei. What did you even bring them here for? Oh, right, to give us 200 shots of them endlessly cheerleading the other contestants, because Eyes wasn’t making enough irritating noise! Seriously, is no one allowed to just watch quietly anymore? It happens all the time on Sasuke, honest!
0:50 Clubhouse! INCREDIBLE SAVE ON SIDEWAYS! She fell in the same spot as Beird but the pad went the other way! (After which she says that the gods were with her, because what this show really needs is more religious fanaticism! ) Hahh…y’know what? I’m never the guy who cries “conspiracy”, but screw it. I’m saying she deliberately tanked that dismount. How could a powerful veteran like her (Did I mention she beat Adam Rayl once? No joke! ) flub the last transition that badly and survive by landing in just the right spot? You expect me to believe that incredible breaks like that just happen? Okay, fine, they do, but let me believe otherwise just this once because it’s the only entertainment value I’m likely to get from this event. At any rate, as one way or other her buzzer was totally undeserved, I will not be pulling for her to win this. Sorry.
(She’s going to run away with this, isn’t she?)
0:59 Yeesh, just watching Corkscrew is painful. I’m amazed that with the tidal wave of injuries we’ve had in recent seasons, no one’s ever strained or dislocated anything on this.
1:00 Goddesses, making the course an upper-body destroyer is even better for an all-women event!
1:10 I swear, by the time they’re done flogging that mother stuff, she’s going to be a grandmother.
1:14 I’m a bit disappointed that Clubhouse didn’t compete in that bikini. Would’ve made a powerful statement and made me a microscopically bit guilty about not rooting for her.
(She’s going to run away with this, isn’t she?)
1:25 Megan Martin takes a nasty fall on Burn Rubber, but since the coverage started at this point it’s a lead pipe cinch that she’s not out, and, yeeeep. And she even goes the distance. I’m starting to think she could be in the final.
1:37 Sweet merciful crap, four on-the-course-right-nows in a row?? Here’s a tip: When you put six contestants on a course modeled after siffies, which normally has the lengthiest runs of the season, and none of them are speed demons but are strong enough that they stand a good chance of making it a long way through the course (all six made it past the 8th obstacle), MAKE SURE YOU HAVE ENOUGH FREAKING AIRTIME TO PROPERLY ACCOMMODATE THEM. This network, man…
1:47 On to the Let’s Get This Over With. Good contest between Meagan Martin and Mady Howard; Martin’s a little stronger and gets a decisive win.
1:50 Clubhouse [mumble grumble mumble grumble] beats Tweb. Feelings of dread intensify.
1:57 [deep, deep sigh] All right, we all know what’s going to happen, so let’s not delay the agony any longer. Martin just a bit behind. Martin still just a bit behind. Struggles a bit on the poles. Running out of time. Clubhouse is on the last pad, while Martin…
MARTIN SURGES AHEAD AND WINS! ALMOST ONE-TIMES THE LAST PAD! IT WASN’T THAT CLOSE! MARTIN WINS! MARTIN WINS! ()
So yeah, good for her. She was always one of the best but never got a big score. Now she has a 10-obstacle completion (the only one of the night, incidentally) and a trophy. Yes, there was a trophy for this stupid contest. And 50 grand, and I’ll spare you the usual whining about second place being worthless because even I’m tired of that by now. This is her high point, her magnum opus. She can retire right now if she wants. Maybe she should.
Overall mood: Next time just have the top four women and have them compete in a variety of contests. There’d be much more of a point than having eight roster-fillers you’re just going to give the bum’s rush anyway. Hayate’s kneepads, when did ANW become so joyless? The Titan Games is starting to look better and better all the time.