First of all, I agree that the woman was irresponsible, careless, wreckless, and an unfit parent. This particular case looks like it may even be murder, and should be investigated as such.
However…
[puts on flame-retardant suit]
In other cases, isn’t there such a thing as an honest mistake? I am not a parent, so if you want to disqualify me with that, there it is. But anyway, there are genuinely times when people have huge lapses in memory or judgment, espcially if they are distracted, overworked, busy, overstressed, etc. Sometimes, one of these lapses may lead to the death of their child… Is it still right to call for their head then?
Say some woman usually has a daily schedule of dropping off three kids, one to elementary school, one to pre-school, and the last one to day-care, and then she goes to work. Say she drops off the first two, then receives a phone call while driving. Meanwhile, the kid in the backseat has fallen asleep. OH SHIT! SOMEONE ROBBED OUR OFFICE LAST NIGHT. THE FILES YOU HAVE BEEN WORKING ON FOR THE PAST TWO MONTHS ON THE COMPUTER ARE GONE. The woman zooms to work and rushes out of the car without looking back, worrying about what is going on with her work, forgetting about her little toddler in the backseat. However, in the course of a normal day, she would have made one more stop, and THEN forgotten about the kid for the rest of the day until it was time to pick them up. So this kid, forgotten because mommy had a crisis at work and momentarily lost track of who she had dropped off (or not dropped off), dies during the day due to heat exposure…
Is the woman at fault? Surely. Is this criminal? I would sincerely hope not.
I am not saying that this fictional story applies to the current case; the woman in this case is looking very suspicious. But I can envision some cases where people make honest mistakes that lead to deadly consequences. In these cases, I would think that these consequences would be more than enough punishment to last a lifetime.
Am I the only one here of this opinion?